When we gathered in 2007 for the first Mock Bracket session, it was like being temporarily invited into a secret society. We would be the first allowed to peer behind the blue curtain (somewhere in Indianapolis there is a warehouse filled with blue draping, bunting and carpeting) and see just how the selection committee chose the NCAA tournament field. And like eager kids we dove right into the whole thing, giddily voting to select teams, digesting every bit of minutiae off the nitty gritty reports, arguing our positions with passion.
By the end of the night, which was actually in the wee hours of the next morning, hepped up on caffeine, bleary eyed and in need of an adult beverage, we were about ready to put anyone in the field just to finish the darned bracket.
I often wondered if the actual selection committee did the same -- just threw up their hands at some point, and said, "Close enough. Let's get a beer."
I wouldn't blame them. If there is a tougher job in sports -- caddying for John Daly, maybe -- I'd like to hear it. Seriously, the last time Selection Sunday ended without controversy or complaint was when? Rumor has it Utah State was ticked back in '39 when it drew Oklahoma.
Someone is always going to be left out or slighted, hate their draw or hate their location. The post-bracket-reveal outrage is as much a part of the Selection Sunday holiday as the unveiling itself, now made so much more instantly gratifying thanks to the ability to share pithy angst in 140 characters or less.
And so on Sunday, the tradition continued.
But honestly, in this of all seasons, how could this bracket be anything but slightly flawed? There's a reason Warren Buffett chose this year to offer $1 billion to the person who could name every tourney winner.
It has been wildly unpredictable, frequently controversial and occasionally even volatile. Pinning down this year into a printable, easy-to-read, clean and geometrically pleasing bracket is about as easy as tacking a noodle to the back of a dolphin. So there was no way the committee could get this thing entirely right.
And they didn't.
My top three beefs:
• There is phoenix rising -- surging Oklahoma State and Kentucky, both rounding back into form after some midseason bumps and bruises -- but no Phoenix. Wisconsin-Green Bay, which played four NCAA tournament teams and beat two of them (Tulsa and Virginia) is out, but an injury-depleted BYU, which lost 11 games, and an NC State that played hardly anyone, are in.
• We started this season talking about a team that could go 40-0 and then when one actually went 34-0, the masochistic branch of the committee laid out the region. In the way of Wichita State and Gregg Marshall's return to the Final Four ... just John Calipari, Rick Pitino, Mike Krzyzewski and John Beilein. Too bad they couldn't exhume John Wooden.
• There is supposed to be room for an eyeball test, a subjective measure of a team's worth. But in some cases the committee clearly borrowed Mr. Magoo's eyeballs. Louisville and Michigan State are 4-seeds?