John Gardner May Be Linked to Other Crimes, Police Say

Police: John Gardner spoke about other cases after sentencing for murders.

BySarah Netter and Brian Braiker via via logo
May 05, 2010, 2:30 PM

May 17, 2010— -- In the hours after he was sentenced to life in prison for the rapes and murders of two southern California teenagers, John Gardner told authorities there are other crimes he may have been involved with.

At a news conference today, officials from several police agencies and the district attorney's office released previously withheld information about the Gardner cases, including the DNA evidence that initially led police to arrest the 31-year-old convicted sex offender in the February murder of 17-year-old Chelsea King.

The investigation into any other crimes Gardner may have committed is ongoing. Officials declined to elaborate on what specific criminal activity he may have been involved with beyond the possibility of other assaults.

Gardner didn't implicate himself in any other murders, police said, but investigators are taking a closer look at every missing persons case in the area involving women in their teens and 20s.

A task force comprised of members of nine agencies, including the FBI, was set up after King's murder to investigate any other crimes that could be tied to Gardner. It is still active even with Gardner behind bars for life.

Police declined to reveal exactly how Gardner was able to overtake King, who was last seen jogging in a park near her home. The DNA evidence that initially linked Gardner to her murder, they said, was "body fluid" on her clothes that would normally be found during the course of a sexual assault.

King's DNA was also on the clothing, they said.

Gardner was sentenced Friday to three consecutive life sentences without parole for the rape and murders of King and 14-year-old Amber DuBois, and the attempted rape of another woman.

Amber DuBois' Mom Tells 'GMA' About Talking With the Killer

Amber's mother, Carrie McGonigle told "Good Morning America" today that Gardner told her in a jailhouse meeting that he forced Amber into his car on Feb. 13, 2009 by trapping her on a fenced street and threatening her with a knife and gun.

He "told her to get in the car or it would be a lot worse for her," McGonigle told "Good Morning America" today. "She had nowhere to go. She was stuck."

McGonigle, who had spoken with Amber about being approached by strangers in the weeks before her murder, pushed hard to meet with Gardner before he was sentenced to learned why he targeted Amber and how he captured her.

"She was in the wrong place at the wrong time," the mom said.

McGonigle said Amber had apparently taken a different route to school that morning for reasons she'll never know. Gardner said he found her one block over from her normal path.

"He said, 'I had a knife and a gun,'" she said. "He says he didn't show it. I don't know."

Gardner has said he drove Amber about a half-hour north of her hometown where he raped and killed her. McGonigle said she intended to keep most of the details of her conversation with Gardner private out of respect for Amber's father and the rest of her family who don't want to hear the details.

"I needed answers," McGonigle said. "I waited 15 months, and I needed some answers."

Gardner's response, she said, gave her closure.

Now focused on her younger daughter, 7-year-old Allison, McGonigle said she needs to let go of the miserable emotions she let overtake her in the past 15 months.

"I don't want to hold on to all that anger and all that hate," she said.

And while she has vowed not to let Amber's death make her unreasonably overprotective of Allison, McGonigle said a recent comment by a construction worker about Allison got to her.

""He said, 'Oh your daughter is beautiful.' I snapped," she said. "I yelled at him. It does rear up."

Confronting a Killer

On Friday, parents of both girls used Gardner's sentencing to speak directly to him, to try to make Gardner understand exactly what he had ripped from their lives.

"You dismantled a family life that was built on love, trust and faith, but you did not destroy it," Kelly King, Chelsea's mother, said Friday. "Look at me!"

Gardner refused to look at her.

Parents of both teens played video tributes to their daughters.

"You have taken a bright shining star from this community and our world away, and for what purpose?" she asked Gardner. "To serve your sick, twisted, perverted mind."

"I hope you suffer 100 times the amount of pain that we have suffered because of your crimes," said Amber's father, Maurice Dubois.

Gardner also pleaded guilty to attempting to rape Candice Moncayo, a 22-year-old jogger, near the spot where he attacked Chelsea.

With his head bowed -- tears staining his kelly-green prison garb -- a seated and shackled Gardner occasionally contorted his face uncomfortably throughout today's hourlong sentencing hearing.

McGonigle said she got a glimpse of the rage Gardner has talked about during sentencing when Moncayo taunted him about his nose, the spot where she hit him to get away.

ABC News Live

ABC News Live

24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events