When should New York City reopen? Cuomo says it's his call

New York City’s mayor and governor are at odds again, this time over who gets to determine the data thresholds that must be surpassed to loosen coronavirus restrictions

NEW YORK -- New York City's mayor unveiled a new set of data thresholds Friday to help determine when to loosen restrictions imposed during the coronavirus pandemic, but his frequent political sparring partner, Gov. Andrew Cuomo, later said it will be up to the state — not the city — to make those decisions.

“No local official can open or close,” Cuomo said, noting that the state has established its own set of metrics intended to measure the safety of reopening.

“We said at the beginning it’s going to be one standard that is data-driven. There’s no politics here. What’s safe is safe," the governor said.

The offices of both Democrats have been saying that the city, among the hardest hit in the world by the virus, is on target to begin reopening its economy in the first half of June.

Mayor Bill de Blasio said Friday that in order to enter the first phase of the reopening, including manufacturing and retail with curbside pickup, the city must stay below thresholds for three things: the daily number of people admitted to hospitals for suspected COVID-19, the total number of patients in intensive care at public hospitals and the citywide percentage of people testing positive for the virus.

“If we do it right, if people stick to the plan, stick to the guidance, we will move to Phase 1 in either the first or second week of June,” the mayor said.

De Blasio had previously said that all three metrics would have to move downward in unison for 10 to 14 days for the city to reopen.

“The day-to-day changes, the small up and downs, matter less,” he said in explaining the new criteria for reopening. “What matters more now is staying at a low level and keeping it that way, and so we’re going to be talking about thresholds now."

Cuomo's standards, which apply to the entire state, are based on measures that include whether a region has seen an overall decline in the number of hospitalizations and the availability of hospital beds.

The indicators used by the city and the state “are in line with one another," and the two administrations are in constant communication, said Cuomo’s top aide, Melissa DeRosa.

“We are aligned in our approach — nothing will reopen until it is safe to do so," de Blasio spokeswoman Jane Meyer said in an interview.

Regional economic reopenings began a week ago in upstate areas, with different industries opening in phases.

Long Island and the mid-Hudson Valley region, including the city’s northern suburbs, are poised to phase economic activity back in next week if COVID-19-related deaths continue to decline and they meet state standards for contact tracing, Cuomo said. Construction companies can begin staging in those regions now, he said.

Other coronavirus developments in New York include:



New York recorded 109 deaths Thursday. The daily death toll is down dramatically from early April but has stubbornly remained at just above 100 for five consecutive days.

Total hospitalizations dropped below 5,000 statewide for the first time since late March. Hospitals still see an average of 225 new patients a day.



A Hasidic Jewish school in the Hudson Valley was ordered to close after officials said it violated a state mandate by remaining open with “hundreds” of boys in the building.

A school in Kiryas Joel was served with a cease-and-desist order Thursday after officials discovered it operating without personal protective equipment and in violation of social distancing rules, the county announced in a statement.

Chris Ericson, a deputy county health commissioner who visited the school, told the Times Herald Record on Friday that the classrooms were filled with students and that very few people wore masks.

The school is part of the United Talmudical Academy, the largest of three ultra-Orthodox Jewish school systems that serve around 14,500 children in the community about 50 miles north of New York City.

Ron Coleman, an attorney for the school system, said that “the school was not operating as a school” but that administrators were allowing the boys to study on their own in the building.

School officials believed that independent study did not count as schooling and that it was allowed under the state’s order, he added.



The public can tune in Tuesday as state lawmakers consider legislation to help New Yorkers.

The state Senate and Assembly expect a few legislative leaders will travel to Albany to debate and vote on bills from their offices or the chambers, while the vast majority of lawmakers will participate from home through video and teleconference.

Several state lawmakers have tested positive for COVID-19, and the Legislature hasn’t been in town since the passage of the state’s budget in early April. Lawmakers held two virtual hearings this week on the impact of COVID-19 on minority communities and small businesses.

It’s unclear which bills lawmakers will take up next week.

Proposals range from banning facial recognition technology in the tracking of COVID-19 to ensuring benefits for workers. Several Republicans and Democrats have introduced bills calling for more oversight and testing of residents at nursing homes.

It’s unclear whether or when lawmakers — who face June 23 primaries and technically have a year-round session — will return again after next week.

The governor says that by the end of May he’ll release a plan that could slash state spending on schools, local governments and hospitals.

New York lacks enough federal aid to make up for a projected $15 billion revenue shortfall. The Democratic-led Legislature could then pass its own plan to balance the budget.



A lawsuit asserts that if Cuomo is allowing small groups to honor veterans and hold religious ceremonies, the Constitution requires the same right be extended to shutdown protesters.

The federal lawsuit filed by the New York Civil Liberties Union takes aim at exceptions to Cuomo’s order in March banning nonessential gatherings of any size. The governor this week modified the order to allow gatherings of as many as 10 people for religious services and Memorial Day commemorations, as long as participants social distance and take other precautions.

The NYCLU filed the lawsuit on behalf of New York City resident Linda Bouferguen, who the group says was twice arrested outside City Hall for protesting the state’s shutdown. She wants to organize another protest Saturday.

The Cuomo administration had no comment.


Associated Press writers Marina Villeneuve and Michael Hill in Albany contributed to this report.