Morningstar is out with its latest ranking of the best and worst mutual fund families, with Dodge & Cox and T. Rowe Price ranking best and second-best, respectively, and Hartford, BlackRock and Alliance Bernstein hugging the bottom.
Asked if anything in this year's rankings surprised him, Russel Kinnel, Morningstar's director of research, says yes: that fund giant Fidelity placed only 22nd.
"I was surprised Fideltiy came in that low," he says. "Their foreign stock funds aren't performing very well. Their muni funds, though, are good." Any other surprises? "Yes, that Hartford was so far down." Hartford ranked 29th, one notch above bottom anchorman ING Retirement Funds, last among the 30 funds.
Morningstar's Top 10 Mutual Fund companies:
1. Dodge & Cox
2. T. Rowe Price
3. American Funds
4. Franklin Templeton Investment
10. Legg Mason/Western
Kinnel says Morningstar's analysis takes into account a variety of metrics for each company: "We take data on all their individual funds and roll them up to see the big picture. All share classes are included, but we exclude funds-of-funds to avoid double counting." Also factored in is each firm's return (its 5-year relative performance), its ability to retain top managers, and how much of their own money managers have invested in the funds they oversee.
Focusing on companies, rather than on funds, says Kinnel, makes sense. "It tells you something about the firm's expertise, its culture and ethics; how good or bad they are at retaining talent." All that matters, he says, because, "when you buy a fund, you're getting the company—its analysts and traders."
The metric for manager-retention, in his view, speaks volumes. "Management retention tells you a lot about a firm's culture," writes Kinnel in his report. "If those who know the company best are fleeing, you probably should not be buying." Top-rated Dodge & Cox gets high marks for manager-retention, with a 5-year retention rate of over 96 percent. Its managers have an average of 21 years with the firm.
Dodge & Cox also rates highly, too, in manager investment (how much of a manager's own money is invested in his or her fund), with the average being $1,000,000, up from $860,000 in 2010. The average at BlackRock, by comparison, is a little over $76,000. More than two thirds of BlackRock's U.S. funds, says Morningstar, have zero manager ownership. The firm placed 26th out of 30 in the overall rankings.