Silicon Insider: Will Hulu Replace YouTube?

Hello Hulu.

Wednesday may be remembered as the day that the Big Media finally began to understand the Internet.

The occasion was the official launch of Hulu, the new broadband video site created by the partnership of NBC and News Corp. The site has been running in private beta since October (and in sorta semi-public mode for the last month) and has already gained 5 million users. That's a long ways from YouTube's 80 million, but having tried Hulu, I predict that it will catch up fast. (Hulu might even consider "graduating" the best new YouTube videos to its site and paying the honorees for the privilege.)

That's not to say that Hulu will ever supplant YouTube. On the contrary, I suspect that they will ultimately develop an interesting symbiotic relationship with each other, with YouTube being the home of the homemade, the obscure and the populist, with Hulu (or another site like it) aggregating the professional-grade productions from movie and television studios. That's not a bad combination for us consumers.

Needless to say, Hulu also has a very different business structure from YouTube. It is not a "free" site, like YouTube. Nor does it operate like iTunes in which you have to purchase content. No, Hulu is going the Third Way, the one the television world knows best: commercials.

That's sure to raise a groan out there among you readers. But the good news is that, from what I've seen, these commercials -- which run at the usual breaks in shows -- seem shorter (no local spots, like television) and of high quality. You don't like them, but you also don't insanely hate them, like we've come to do with broadcast TV commercial breaks.

What this means, in other words, is that Hulu is trying to find that sweet spot where it can compete with the online content providers, from Apple to the zillions of pirates out there, while still bringing to bear 60 years of market research and tools to maximize revenues. And this is hardly an idle exercise: with 18-25-year-olds turning away from TV toward MySpace and online gaming, the networks are looking at an aging audience -- the kind of folks who most advertisers shun.

So there is a touch of desperation in all of this. Big Media, from the music industry to TV to movies to newspapers to magazines and radio, have so far not only largely missed the boat on the Web economy but, in some cases, have made decisions so catastrophic that they will be taught as object lessons in MBA programs for a generation. Even now, it's hard to understand the reasoning behind the newspaper industry retiring or firing all of its best talent to compete with a new generation of online journalists, or the music industry deciding to sue or call the cops on its most ardent customers.

That's why the whole media world is watching the Hulu launch to see if this new business model will work. If it fails, they haven't a lot of options left.

So, the question is: Is Hulu any good? Walt Mossberg of The Wall Street Journal, the leading arbiter on all products and services electronic, gave Hulu the kind of thumbs up he usually reserves only for Apple products. That's a good sign.

Page
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
  • |
  • 3
Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...