Both artists in their mid-30s with limited incomes, they are taking a chance on moving from Chicago to a declining, working-class neighborhood of single-family homes, mostly built in the 1920s, in Hamtramck, Mich., a city on the eastern edge of Detroit.
"People feel very inclined to tell us, 'That's very dangerous. I don't know why you'd do that,'" Brumit said.
Their reasons are more than economic. They were recruited to the neighborhood by another pair of artists, Mitch Cope, 35, and Gina Reichert, 34, whose lives were already bound up in the risks of living there. For better or worse, Cope and Reichert saw a flicker of hope amid the ruins.
New statistics released Thursday show that Detroit's unemployment rate, already the highest of any large American city, rose to 22 percent from 17 percent between November and January. During the worst days of the 1930s Depression, national unemployment reached 25 percent.
More than 11,000 homes have been foreclosed in Detroit. The neighborhood where Brumit and Wagner are moving, and where Cope and Reichert already live, is one of the ground zeroes of the foreclosure crisis. It was once a Polish enclave, but is now a mixed neighborhood of Polish, African-American and Bangladeshi residents.
Three years ago, Cope and Reichert bought a former Polish deli that they converted to an art studio and home. They also run a storefront gallery called Design 99 not far from where they live.
When the foreclosure crisis hit, "a lot of houses started going empty," Cope said. "And that's when we became interested in doing something."
One reason home prices have plummeted so dramatically is that banks and mortgage holders simply want to clear the books of properties that generate tax obligations, maintenance and code violation fees. In the stock market, it's called "capitulation."
Thieves have stripped abandoned homes of wiring and other valuable scrap items. Some homes have been burned by arsonists or squatters.
Cope's and Reichert's concerns struck close to home when the house next door to them went vacant. Rather than leaving it as a magnet for vandals, they explored buying the house themselves and found it listed in a foreclosure auction for a price that seemed impossibly low: $500.
"The starting bid on everything in the auction was $500," Reichert said. "And, so basically, no one bid against us."
Cope said, "We liked the house because it was smaller, would be more manageable, and was also in really good shape."
Cope runs into resistance when he tries to chase scrap thieves and vandals away from vacant properties.
"There were these teenage kids that threatened to burn our house down, and I just looked at them," he said. "I go, 'What's that going to do? You're going to burn it down. I'll still be here.'"
Even with the crime, blight and vandalism, Cope and Reichert don't want to leave.
"There's crime everywhere," Cope said. "So, for me, it was stake your ground and just learn to deal with it and try to change it somehow."
In staking their ground, Cope and Reichert bought another house for $1,900, money borrowed from their parents. They hope to convert it to a self-sufficient neighborhood power center with solar and wind technology.