Shipping Showdown: Who Gets Your Package There Fastest and Cheapest

Dec. 18, 2006 — -- Today marks the busiest shipping day of the year, according to the U.S. Postal Service.

Shipping choices are plenty, and so is the price range and predictability that the package will arrive on time.

So what is the best, cheapest way to make sure your gifts get to their destinations on time?

"Good Morning America" went shopping for some answers.

"GMA's" plan was to send six boxes across the country by two-day mail. Each box would contain exactly the same thing -- so all the boxes weighed the same and would be sent to the same place.

The boxes began their journey from New York City, using Federal Express, DHL, the U.S. Post Office, UPS, Mail Boxes Etc., and Post Express, a local "mom-and-pop" shipping company.

The lowest price option, at just $14, was the U.S. Post Office's priority mail, where items were supposed to arrive within two days or three days. Be aware, though, that the post office does not guarantee arrival in that time.

The express carriers ranged from $30 to $37. When we went to stores that offered shipping services, however, the price jumped an extra $8 to $15, using the same carriers.

Those services also charged extra for Saturday delivery; some also added on a fuel surcharge. The shipping stores didn't necessarily offer us more services, so why bother with the extra cost?

Mail Boxes Etc. said it provided "shipping services from all major carriers, for which they can set their own prices. … There can be additional costs for special services and other handling fees."

All of the express carriers arrived on time to our producer on the West Coast; even a few arrived a day earlier than expected.

The box sent by the U.S. Post Office, the cheapest option, took more than three days.