The Price of an Afghan Life: $5280

The case took its last, critical turn in July. The burly man was back to negotiating with the victims' attorneys. The lawyers' supposed demand for a €200,000 fee and the "unclear situation regarding the clients" -- in short, all the things that had prompted the Defense Ministry to suspend negotiations only three months earlier -- were suddenly irrelevant.

'Constructive Conversations'

Popal and Docke, demoralized and on edge, were no longer directly involved in the negotiations. Instead, they were being represented by two other attorneys with experience in cases against the Bundeswehr, Remo Klinger and Reiner Geulen, as well as Wolfgang Kaleck, a human rights attorney and general secretary of the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights. The men were now part of Popal's legal team.

The negotiations continued throughout July. Once again, there was talk of "constructive conversations" and projects, including the construction of a hospital in Kunduz. The teams met three times. Meanwhile, the Bundeswehr was busy creating a fait accompli in Afghanistan.

Bundeswehr employees prepared a list of 102 people entitled to compensation, and then they met and negotiated with the families of the victims. Each family was offered a monetary payment of about €4,000 or $5,000. Accounts were opened at the Kabul Bank in Kunduz, and many of the victims' families accepted the Bundeswehr's offer. They needed the money. After all the investigations, lists of casualties and unsuccessful negotiations of the last few months, they were ready to accept any compensation at all.

The Last Word?

The negotiations continued in Berlin, and a meeting was scheduled for Aug. 10. The attorneys were not unhappy with the way the talks were going. An agreement seemed within reach.

But on Aug. 5, the Defense Ministry informed the attorneys that, for "humanitarian reasons" and "without recognition of a legal obligation," it had come to an agreement with the victims' families. The newspapers, news agencies and television networks reported that the Kunduz case had finally been brought to a close.

It sounded like the last word.

If anyone in this case can be characterized as a winner, it could well be the burly man from the Defense Ministry. At the beginning of the year, he and the attorneys were still negotiating over aid projects worth up to €9 million. Now the Bundeswehr will be paying $5,000 -- not for each life that was lost, but to each family of a victim or multiple victims. In other words, all families will receive the same compensation, no matter how many of their members were killed in the Kunduz bombing. And the cost to the Bundeswehr? Half a million dollars.

Not a bad outcome for a lead negotiator.

Just a Fender Bender

In the past, Germany has paid $20,000 to the family of an Afghan woman who was shot at a checkpoint, and $33,000 for a dead Afghan boy. The price has apparently gone down since then. This is partly the result of pressure from Germany's NATO allies. Before, the Germans were seen as driving up prices in Afghanistan. The Kunduz bombing, Germany's war trauma, its big case, is now a $5,000 case. Little more than a wartime fender bender, if you will.

Page
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
PHOTO: A visitor holds an Xbox One controller during the EGX gaming conference at Earls Court in London, Sept. 25, 2014.
Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg/Getty Images
PHOTO:
Bay Ismoyo, ChaideerMahyuddin/AFP/Getty Images
PHOTO: An undated booking photo shows Castor Conley.
Multnomah County Sheriffs Office
PHOTO: James Franco, left, and Seth Rogen in a scene from the The Interview.
Ed Araquel/Columbia Pictures/Sony/AP Photo
Minecraft Creator Buys Ridiculous $70 Million Mansion
MLS | Inset: Yui Mok/Press Association/AP Photo