California Gay Marriage Case to Conclude First Round in Federal Court
California judge to decide first round in challenge to Proposition 8.
June 16, 2010— -- A federal judge in California heard closing arguments today in the landmark legal case that will determine the constitutionality of California's same-sex marriage ban, first approved by voters as Proposition 8 in November 2008.
The ballot measure, launched in response to a state supreme court decision allowing gays and lesbians to wed, took effect after 18,000 same-sex marriages had been performed in California, sparking a fierce legal and political debate. Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker will now weigh whether the measure amounts to unconstitutional discrimination.
Supporters of Prop 8 have argued that voters endorsed a "fundamental, definitional feature" of marriage that has historical roots "in this country and, almost without exception, in every civilized society that has ever existed."
But the plaintiffs in the case -- one lesbian and one gay couple -- say the legacy of restricting marriage to a man and a woman is "constitutionally inadequate ground" for denying same-sex partners a "vital personal right" protected by the 14th Amendment providing equal protection.
Walker's decision, which is not expected for several weeks, will likely be appealed and may ultimately reach the U.S. Supreme Court, where a decision could have the potential to transform social and legal precedent like the famous 1954 Brown v. Board of Education decision, which desegregated schools, and the 1967 Loving v. Virginia decision, which ended laws banning interracial marriage.
Lawyers for both sides made their final case in court today and responded to a series of questions submitted by Judge Walker last week in advance of the hearing.
Representing the plaintiffs are a pair of unusual bedfellows: former Republican Solicitor General Ted Olson and Democrat David Boies, who opposed Olson in the Bush v. Gore case before the Supreme Court in 2000.
Attorney Andy Pugno, of the conservative advocacy group Protect Marriage, and former Justice Department lawyer Charles Cooper are defending Proposition 8, after neither California Attorney General Jerry Brown nor Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger moved to defend the measure on behalf of the state.
Related Stories
ABC News Live