One of the jurors who helped put Ryan Ferguson behind bars almost a decade ago said he was "very" sorry and is now convinced Ferguson is innocent.
"We took away 10 years of his life," the man said. "He can never get that back."
The juror, whose identity is not being revealed, sat down for an interview with "Nightline" today, one day after 29-year-old Ferguson of Columbia, Mo., was released from prison when his 2004 murder conviction was overturned.
If given the chance to speak to Ferguson today, the juror said he would "apologize a million times over."
"I would apologize a million times over, telling him I'm sorry," he said. "That still wouldn't be enough."
In 2005, a jury convicted Ferguson, then just 19 years old, of brutally murdering Columbia Daily Tribune sports editor Kent Heitholt in the Tribune parking lot on Halloween night 2001.
None of the DNA collected at the scene -- the footprints and fingerprints -- matched Ferguson's, but the jury decided that testimony from Charles Erickson, one of Ferguson's classmates who claimed they had murdered Heitholt together, and Jerry Trump, a janitor who identified Ferguson as one of the two men he saw in the parking lot after the murder, was enough to convict him.
Based on their testimony, the juror said the 12-member jury's decision to convict Ferguson was unanimous.
"Charles Erickson and Jerry Trump hold a lot of weight in our minds," he said. "Everybody had the same feeling that because of Mr. Erickson and Mr. Trump that yes, he was guilty."
The juror also blamed Ferguson's trial lawyer at the time, saying he was "very hard to follow" and not very effective at delivering his case.
Ferguson was sentenced to 40 years in prison. Erickson was also convicted and sentenced to 25 years. He remains in prison.
Last April, both Erickson and Trump recanted their statements, saying they had lied under oath at the initial 2004 murder trial.
Upon learning that Erickson and Trump recanted, the juror said he was "shocked."
"I thought [Ferguson] should be released, and then I thought Ryan Ferguson should be released immediately," he said. "[I was] shocked and disappointed in myself for knowing that I probably did the wrong thing. But yet I had no way of making it right."
However, the juror was unsure that, even with the recanted testimony, Ferguson's fate would have been different.
"If you had to go and do that whole trial again and knowing then what we knew, I don't know if the outcome would be different," he said. "I can't say that because for now I know more and I just-- I don't know."
A Missouri state appeals court panel last week overturned Ferguson's murder conviction on the grounds that the prosecution withheld evidence from Ferguson's defense attorneys.
When Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster announced Tuesday that he would not retry or seek further legal action against Ferguson, the 29-year-old Columbia, Mo., man was allowed to leave prison once a Boone County judge signed off on the order. Ferguson, who maintained his innocence while serving a 40-year sentence for the 2001 slaying of the newspaper editor, was released from custody Tuesday evening.