Controversy raged in Israel today after a rabbi who heads the biggest ultra-Orthodox political party said the six million Jews who perished in the Nazi Holocaust died because they were reincarnations of sinners.
Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, leader of the Shas party, also declared that Prime Minister Ehud Barak has “no sense” because he is trying to make peace with the Palestinians, who are “snakes.”
Yosef was speaking in his weekly Saturday night sermon broadcast over the party’s radio stations and is even beamed overseas by satellite.
He called the Nazis “evil” and the victims “poor people,” but he said the six million “were reincarnations of the souls of sinners, people who transgressed and did all sorts of things which should not be done. They had been reincarnated in order to atone.”
Comments Stir Controversy
Barak told the cabinet today the statement is unworthy of a rabbi of Yosef’s status. “His words could harm the memory of those who perished in the Holocaust and could hurt the feelings of their families and the feelings of the entire nation,” the prime minister said.
Legislator Yosef (Tommy) Lapid, who heads the secularist Shinui party, said Rabbi Yosef is “an old fool” who has done a service to those who are trying to rehabilitate Adolf Hitler’s reputation.
“In the world it will be said that a distinguished rabbi in Israel is in effect confirming what Hitler said, that the Jews are sinners,” said Lapid, who is himself a Holocaust survivor.
The two main radio stations were inundated with phone calls and messages, most of them criticizing Yosef’s statement. Yehoshua Mashav, a listener, told Israel radio that in plain language Yosef was saying Hitler was innocent and that “he was simply the messenger of God sent to give the Jewish people their just deserts.”
We Are All Sinners
The Simon Wiesenthal Center, an international center for Holocaust remembrance, said the rabbi absolved the perpetrators of the Holocaust of their responsibility. “If those Jews deserved to die for past sins, why blame those who carried out the death sentence?” said Ephraim Zuroff, director of the group’s Jerusalem office.
Israel’s Chief Rabbi Israel Meir Lau, who is also a Holocaust survivor, said Judaism has a concept of reincarnation and of the righteous dying to atone for sin in a previous life, but he told Israel radio that did not account for the Holocaust.
“I have no explanation for the Holocaust,” said Lau, who was a child at the time and lost most of his family in the death camps. He appealed to Israelis to “stop probing into it [the Holocaust] in such a blatant, painful, hurtful manner.”
Shas chairman Eli Ishai said criticism of Yosef is unjustified. “Rabbi Ovadia weeps for every Jew who is killed ... but nobody, not even a saint, has not sinned. Everyone dies in a state of sin. Nobody can be perfect all his life.”
Not Exactly Promoting Tolerance
Yosef, who ordered Shas to quit Barak’s coalition as the prime minister was leaving for the Camp David summit, described the Arabs as “snakes” interested mainly in murdering Jews. He said Barak, who is trying to achieve a permanent peace with the Palestinians, has “no sense.”
“What kind of peace is this?” Yosef said. “Will you put them beside us? You are bringing snakes beside us. ... Will we make peace with a snake?”
Col. Jebril Rajoub, head of the Palestinian Preventive Security Service in the West Bank, said Yosef’s statement about Arabs was racist. A religious leader should be trying to promote tolerance among Jews, Muslims and Christians, Rajoub told Israel radio.