Chef Rick Bayless Prompts Question: What Makes Mexican Food Mexican?

Comments by chef Rick Bayless prompts question of what makes food "Mexican"

ByABC News
April 16, 2013, 12:14 PM

April 17, 2013— -- In case you don't already know him, Rick Bayless is a well-known chef, television host, and cookbook author who specializes in Mexican cuisine -- specifically traditional regional cooking. Recently, a Zagat reporter talked to Bayless about San Francisco's food scene while he was in the city for the International Association of Culinary Professional's Conference and Awards.

When asked whether he had the chance to check out the newer, upscale Mexican restaurants in town, Bayless responded that "San Francisco doesn't really have much of a Mexican food tradition aside from the taquerias in the Mission, which is a fairly limited thing."

The interview, and that comment in particular, garnered some attention among locals, including an SFist post titled "Rick Bayless Bored By S.F. Food Scene" and an editorial piece in OC Weekly, "Rick Bayless Insults Yet Another California City's Mexican Food Traditions."

Both articles mentioned a previous, similar comment Bayless made (or didn't make, as Bayless himself maintains) about introducing Southern California diners to "authentic" Mexican cuisine. Long story short: In 2010, Pulitzer Prize-winning food writer Jonathan Gold, addressing attendees as a fund-raiser for an association of Latino journalists, criticized Bayless for his role in Red O, a restaurant that, as he characterized it, positioned itself as introducing authentic Mexican food to Los Angeles -- a city long-influenced by Mexicans, Mexican-Americans, and their respective, often overlapping food traditions. Bayless responded to Gold's comments online, tweeting directly to Gold that he "[t]hought a Pulitzer meant you checked facts. Sneering at me for something I never said is either mean or sloppy. I'm offended."

Bayless is defending himself this time, too. In the comments thread for his Zagat interview, Bayless explained that he had not initially realized he was being interviewed, adding that there "is a lot of Mexican food in SF, but it isn't very similar to what I eat in Mexico. When people talk to me about Mexican in SF, they are usually talking about great tacos and burritos in the Mission. I think most people would agree that SF isn't well know for a plethora of Mexican dinner restaurants."