Good Morning America Recipes

Feasty Halloween Caramel Pie

Halloween Recipes from the Feasty Boys

GMA Recipes Dessert
Difficulty: Easy
Cook Time: min

Are you looking for a special Halloween meal? The Feasty Boys -- Jon Mayer and Jim Stump of the popular ESPN show "The Feasty Boys" -- showed "Good Morning America Weekend Edition" how to make Hallo"weenies" and beanies and feasty Halloween caramel pie.


  • 1 frozen pie crust
  • 2 six-ounce cans sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 Red Delicious apples, sliced
  • whipped cream
  • Cooking Directions

    Remove wrappers from cans of condensed milk and place, unopened, into a large pot. Add enough water to completely cover cans. Place pot on stove and bring to a slow boil. (It's important that the water is brought to a slow boil and maintained. Below a boil the milk won't cook, and too rapid a boil could cause the cans to explode). Allow pot to boil for 2 1/2 hours, adding water as needed to keep the cans completely submerged. Once cans have sufficiently boiled from from heat, carefully remove the cans from hot water with tongs and set them aside for approx. 5 minutes to allow minimal cooling.

    While the cans boil, place pie crust in the oven and bake as directed. Set aside and allow to cool.

    Approximately 30 minutes prior to the conclusion of the cans cooking, thinly slice apples and place in a medium-sized bowl of water with a few squirts of lemon juice to prevent browning.

    While the cans cool, line the pie crust with sliced apples. Carefully open the cans and spoon caramel (which the condensed milk turned into) into the pie crust atop apples. Distribute evenly and place in refrigerator to cool. Top with whipped cream, slice and serve.

    For that extra Halloween twist, omit the apples and simply top the caramel with some leftover Halloween candy -- M&Ms or chopped Snickers, Milky Way, Twix, peanut brittle, etc.

    Recipe Summary

    Main Ingredients: condensed milk, apples

    Course: Dessert

    Other Recipes That You Might Like
    Hallo'weenies' and Beanies
    Halloween Recipes from the Feasty Boys
    Feasy Boys' Easy Mini Caramel Pies
    These Small Pies Make an Easy Dessert or Snack
    Slow Cooker Caramel Apples
    A Healthy Alternative To Your Sugar Fix
    Recipe: Caramel Pecan Apple Pie
    Drizzled With Caramel Sauce, This Pie Is Perfect for Bake Sales
    Rocco DiSpirito's Caramel Apples
    Try This Healthy Version
    Carla Hall's Caramel Apples
    Celebration Cooking
    Latest Recipes on 'GMA'
    VIDEO: The Ramen Burger
    VIDEO: Rays & Stark Bar in LA employs an expert to help you choose from 20 brands of water.
    VIDEO: Haylee Nelson reveals all the delicious flavors that make up the new "Sunrise Sundae."
    VIDEO: Ladies and Gentlemen... The Crookie
    VIDEO: World, meet The Cronut
    Food Tips: How To...
    Karen's Kitchen
    Check out "GMA's" chef/food stylist's blog here.
    Karen's Cordon Bleu
    Check out "GMA's" chef/food stylist's delicious and celebratory chicken dish.
    PHOTO: Karen Pickus cherry galette is shown here.
    Karen's Cherry Galette Check out "GMA's" chef/food stylist's recipe for a tasty dessert.
    Connect with GMA
    Social Tools Facebook Twitter Twitter Connect with GMA YouTube RSS