New book touts inside story of Tom Brady, the Patriots and the 2015 'Deflategate' saga

A new book looks inside one of the most controversial NFL scandals in years.

ByABC News
August 2, 2018, 1:54 PM

A new book reports that in order to avoid his four-game suspension in 2015 over what became known as “Deflategate,” star New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady offered to pay a $1 million fine, but that wasn’t enough for National Football League (NFL) Commissioner Roger Goodell.

"He demanded that Brady state publicly that former Patriots equipment guys [John] Jastremski and [Jim] McNally had purposely tampered with footballs, even without his knowledge," authors Casey Sherman and Dave Wedge write in their new book "12: The Inside Story of Tom Brady’s Fight for Redemption."

"Tom said no."

“There’s no way I’m gonna ruin these guys for something I believe they didn’t do,” Brady is said to have told DeMaurice Smith, executive director of the NFL Players Association and Brady’s legal representative, according to the book.

PHOTO: In this undated photo shows the cover of "12: The Inside Story of Tom Brady's Fight for Redemption."
In this undated photo shows the cover of "12: The Inside Story of Tom Brady's Fight for Redemption."
Little, Brown and Company

The new book details the infamous 544-day saga which began in January 2015 when the New England Patriots were accused of using under-inflated footballs in the American Football Conference (AFC) Championship game.

The Patriots won that game, sending the team to Super Bowl XLIX in Phoenix, Arizona.

The subsequent battle between the NFL and their top-tier quarterback played out first in private NFL arbitration meetings, but ultimately escalated into a federal court fight, before ultimately landing Tom Brady the four-game suspension and banishment from all Patriots facilities for a month.

You might hate him and he might beat your team all the time, [but

A spokesperson for the NFL declined to comment on the new book, and neither the Patriots nor Brady himself immediately responded to requests for comment about "12."

The book describes the tension within the Patriots organization as Brady watched Patriots owner Robert Kraft accept Brady’s four-game suspension and vow not to appeal the NFL’s decision, in a press conference broadcast in the spring of 2015.

"Kraft’s star quarterback Tom Brady watched the news conference along with millions of others on television," the authors write in the book. "He was devastated and angry. Brady grabbed his cell phone and punched in the contact number for DeMaurice Smith."

“What the f--?” Brady shouted into the phone. “Why am I not getting the support I deserve on this thing?"

Smith assured Brady that the union would fight on his behalf, and they did -- appealing the NFL arbitrator’s decision in court for more than a year.

Sherman told ABC News that Kraft would only talk to the authors off-the-record about his current relationship with Goodell, and said that the team owner was reticent to revisit the controversial press conference.

“Publicly Kraft had to make peace with Goodell," Sherman said. "But privately in our conversations, there is still a lot of anger and disappointment that the NFL went as far as they did to tar and feather Tom Brady.”

Similarly, Brady was reluctant during a 2017 interview with the authors to delve back into that period of his career.

“It’s not what [Brady] said," Sherman asserted. "It’s what he is not saying. His silence on Kraft and what he went through -- and especially on [Patriots coach Bill] Belichick -- speaks volumes on how he really feels.”

Sherman said that while fractures in the relationship remain, tensions between Kraft and Brady have largely been repaired.

Kraft has "great affection for Brady and also tremendous anger, still, towards the NFL and what they did to [Brady]," Sherman told ABC News.

But Sherman claims that Belichick and Brady do not maintain a similar relationship.

“It’s always been a business relationship between the two of them," Sherman said. "But now, it’s something even more acrimonious.”

Soon after the initial NFL investigation began in 2015, Brady gave a pre-Super Bowl press conference at the Patriots' Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts. Sherman and Wedge said that Brady completely ignored advice from the Patriots and the NFL Players Association not to speak out in a press conference.

“I didn’t alter the ball in any way,” Brady told reporters at the press conference, according to the book. When asked if he was a cheater, the quarterback responded, “I don’t believe so.”

“Tom gave the press conference because he didn’t think the situation was a big deal and that he hadn’t done anything wrong,” Smith, the NFL players union representative, told the authors for the book. "He thought he would address it once and move on."

“His minor infraction became a capital murder case,” Sherman said in the ABC News interview.

Sherman went on to say that, at most, he views Brady as an unwitting co-conspirator, but believes that the Patriots equipment guys had to have known that they were in violation of NFL policy.

PHOTO: New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady during a break in an NFL football minicamp practice, June 6, 2018, in Foxborough, Mass.
New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady during a break in an NFL football minicamp practice, June 6, 2018, in Foxborough, Mass.
Elise Amendola/AP, FILE

Wedge, who has Boston roots and described himself as both a Patriots and a Brady fan, said it didn’t affect his work as a journalist on the book.

“I followed the facts where they took me," he said. "If we had found some smoking gun that implicated him – we would have reported that. We didn’t find that. Conversely we didn’t find anything that exonerated it."

Sherman, who has worked extensively with the Central Intelligence Agency and the Federal Bureau of Investigation on other investigations, said he had a harder time extracting information on the Deflategate story than during his work with those organizations.

"12" is Sherman and Wedge's third book together. The duo are also behind the stories of the hit movies "The Finest Hours" and "Patriots Day."

The authors are currently meeting with studio heads and potential lead actors for an adaptation of “12”.

Sherman said that while he can’t elaborate on top contenders to play Brady, he promised that “it won’t be a Boston guy –- not Wahlberg or Damon. We have to find an actor that can pull off both the physicality and vulnerability of Brady.”

Sherman said that in interviewing Brady, he and Wedge were struck by his vulnerability -- something Sherman doesn’t believe many people understand about the Patriots quarterback.

“We thought he was decent guy," Sherman said. "He gave thoughtful answers and took his time to offer a true opinion. It was very refreshing.”

“You might hate him and he might beat your team all the time, [but] you have to respect him and all the challenges he’s had," Wedge added.

"He’s great for the sport."

ABC News Live

ABC News Live

24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events