Hagel to Lawmakers: Why We Didn't Tell You About Bergdahl


Hagel said those men, who will live in Qatar for a year, will be subject to “risk mitigation measures” such as travel restrictions, monitoring, information sharing between the U.S. and Qatar and “limitations on activities,” among other restrictions Hagel promised to explain in more detail in a classified setting.

“As Secretary of Defense, I have the authority and responsibility to determine whether detainees at Guantanamo Bay can be transferred to the custody of another country. I take that responsibility damn seriously, damn seriously,” Hagel said.

When asked by Conaway if the five individuals will “strengthen the Taliban and their efforts to do whatever it is they want to do in Afgahnistan,” Hagel responded, “Maybe… We don’t know.”

FULL COVERAGE: Bowe Bergdahl

The Obama administration’s decision to trade five notorious Taliban figures for Bergdahl, whom fellow soldiers accuse of walking off his Afghan base on his own before his capture, has been a controversial one, dividing the country with more Americans disapproving of the exchange than approving, according to a new ABC News/Washington Post poll.

Lawmakers also rankled after they were not consulted about the exchange, noting that the National Defense Authorization Act calls on Congress to be notified 30 days ahead of any transfers from Guantanamo Bay. The President added a “signing statement” to the NDAA in which the administration claimed that such a restriction was, “under certain circumstances,” a violation of constitutional separation of powers and warned the administration would implement them “in a manner that avoids the constitutional conflict.”

Hagel had several tense exchanges with lawmakers over the cost of freeing Bergdahl. He acknowledged that war is “dirty” and that the solution was “imperfect.”

“You don’t send them chocolates and they’ll send him over. [It’s a] tough business,” Hagel said.

Hagel also clashed with Rep. Jeff Miller, R-Florida, over Bergdahl’s treatment at a military medical facility in Germany. Miller said he wanted to know why Bergdahl had not already been brought home to answer questions about his disappearance nearly five years ago. Hagel had said earlier the Army will launch a "comprehensive, coordinated effort" to find out exactly how Bergdahl fell into the Taliban's hands, including questioning Bergdahl.

“Why hasn’t he been returned to the United States? We have seriously wounded soldiers that are returned to the United States almost immediately after they are stabilized… You’re trying to tell me that he’s being held at Landstuhl, Germany, because of his medical condition?” Miller asked.

“Congressman, I hope you’re not implying anything other than that. The fact is -” Hagel said.

“I’m just asking the question, Mr. Secretary, and you won’t answer,” Miller said.

“I’m going to give an answer too, and I don’t like the implication of the question,” Hagel said.

“Well answer it! Answer it! Answer it!” Miller said, voice rising into the microphone.

“He’s being held there because our medical professionals don’t believe he’s ready until they’re – until they believe he is ready to take the next step to his rehabilitation,” Hagel said. Hagel later added, “This isn’t just about a physical situation, Congressman. This guy was held for almost five years in God knows what kind of conditions… This is not just about, can he gt on his feet and walk and get on a plane.”

Hagel said that until military investigators can determine exactly what happened to Bergdahl, he still "has rights."

"Like any American, Sergeant Bergdahl has rights, and his conduct will be judged on facts – not political hear-say, posturing, charges, or innuendo. We owe that to any American and especially those who are members of our military and their families," Hagel said.

CLICK HERE to return to the ABC News Investigative Unit homepage.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...