'127 Hours': A Movie Good for the Soul, for the Body Maybe Not So Much

Photo: James Franco in 127 Hours
Share
Copy

How about an oxygen mask to go with that movie ticket and popcorn?

Usually people go to see flicks to escape the real world. But sometimes what's on screen is so realistically depicted that the visceral impact can literally make audience members ill.

The highly anticipated "127 Hours," which opens today and stars James Franco, is the latest movie to deliver that sort of punch to the gut.

Franco portrays real-life Aron Ralston, an avid outdoorsman who, seven years ago, went on a solitary hike. While in the deep recesses of a canyon in Utah, an 800 pound boulder fell on his right arm and trapped it.

The movie, based on Ralston's book "Between a Rock and a Hard Place," culminates in Ralston freeing himself – by self-amputating his trapped arm.

Franco's character's liberating deed didn't have a salutary effect on everyone who watched it. On Sunday, an article in the Los Angeles Times noted that a partial tally of film festival attendees found six people who collapsed during the movie's screening. One person who attended a guild screening commented that she felt as though she was going to throw up while watching the amputation scene. After turning dizzy, she fainted. Another attendee suffered an apparent seizure.

The Times article quoted Stephen Gilula, an executive from FoxSearchlight, which released the movie, who said, "I would prefer that people not pass out – it's not a plus." Nevertheless, Gilula said there had been at least eight other swoons at other preview screenings.

The physiological reactions are not surprising.

"It's natural to recoil when we see someone hurt or, at the next level, see someone hurt themselves," said Terrence Sheehan, a physiatrist with an expertise in amputations, and the medical director of the Amputee Coalition of America. "But when you see someone cutting through soft tissue through the bone with a crude tool, it's cringe-inducing."

"About 15 percent of people who have blood-injury phobia are predisposed to fainting," said Scott Bea, a clinical psychologist, with a specialty in anxiety and mood disorders, at the Cleveland Clinic.

But It's Only the Movies, Right?

But why would viewers who know they're watching a movie –entertainment that's not real – faint or become nauseous?

"Watching something this unpleasant on screen could set off a fight-or-flight response, said Steven Schlozman, a child psychiatrist and assistant professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.

What follows next, he described, is the vasovagal response, in which blood doesn't make its way to the brain as fast as it should, which leads to feeling faint, lightheaded or sweaty.

"Even though, intellectually, you know you have nothing to worry about, because it's only a movie, what you see is so frightening that the body reacts," he said.

But, noted Harvard's Schlozman, there's also the important phenomenon known as the mirror neuron response theory.

"We've seen in primate studies that the brain contains specific neurons that become activated when they watch someone else go through a painful or frightening experience," said Schlozman. "The observing primate would feel what the experiencing primate felt.

"Similar brain-imaging studies have been conducted with humans using fMRIs, in which humans observing the actions of other humans can somehow participate in the experience. It's the physiological model for empathy."

What makes the amputation scene in "127 Hours" extraordinarily compelling is "the character is all alone and has no other way to free himself. The movie wants you in the shoes of the character it's portraying, and really draws you in," said Schlozman.

State-of-the-art special effects –the amputation scene in "127 Hours" involved several prosthetic arms full of fake blood, muscles, ligaments, nerves and bone, which Franco's character hacked his way through – also make the experience disturbingly graphic.

Other Movies That Might Make You Ill

Here are more movies possessing that rare power to totally capture viewers' minds and hearts – and wreak havoc on their bodies.

"The Blair Witch Project."

This low-budget scare-inducing flick, shot for a song, made more than a handful of viewers lose their lunch. Sure, the fear-factor was high – the movie's characters set out to document the region's legendary witch in a desolate area. When the group begins to hear and see strange things, much is left to the imagination. But the even bigger culprit was the hand-held film camera.

The jostling up-and-down motion can affect viewers, even if they're glued to their movie house seats, said Thomas A. Stoffregen, a motion sickness expert, and professor at the School of Kinesiology at the University of Minnesota.

"Even if you're sitting, your body is not entirely stationary," he said. "As you watch the on-screen images bobbing, your body is subtly swaying, and so you're not entirely in control of your neck and torso, which may lead you to become physically unstable in your seat." This phenomenon can lead to nausea, eyestrain and dizziness, he said. An easy fix is simply closing your eyes, which eliminates the stimulus.

"Saving Private Ryan."

Few films have dared to portray war's brutality like this. On the battlefield, bodies explode, and limbs which are torn apart fly through the air. A medic's guts are graphically displayed. On seeing these types of images, explained Sheehan, the body releases certain neurotransmitters that may cause physical reactions such as nausea and vomiting, and even fainting. In addition, he said, viewers who are blocked from quickly exiting the theater may pass out.

"Paranormal Activity."

"Any movie that deals with potential harm from supernatural forces can have a huge impact, because people can't verify that these occurrences can never happen," said Bea. The reason, he explained, is these otherworldly forces are completely unknown and, therefore, very alarming. Possible medical repercussions can include increased vigilance, and fear of being alone, especially in the dark.

"Cloverfield."

"In this movie, which is filled with rapid-cut edits, the eye is getting pulled every which way," said Stoffregen. "You lose a lot of control over where your eye goes." Potential medical repercussions include eyestrain and headaches, he said, adding that, if you don't look away to stop the stimulus, you may eventually vomit.

"Interview With the Vampire."

Not for those with phobias about violence and blood, "Interview" made its gore even more twisted by having the mayhem performed by rather attractive people. "This incongruity between the handsome perpetrators and the grueling deeds can make the physical reactions even stronger," said Schlozman. Potential medical repercussions include lightheadedness, nausea and vomiting.

"2001: A Space Odyssey."

"Towards the end of the movie, Dr. Dave Bowman travels though space in an extended sequence full of special effects and flashing lights," said Stoffregen. "The visuals really make viewers feel as though they're moving through space, with a disorienting stomach-in-your mouth feeling that might include nausea and dizziness."

"The Godfather."

The slow and dramatic unfolding of the severed horse head in the bed was, for many, an eye-shutting moment. "That bloody scene was horrifying," said Sheehan, noting that physical reactions could include nausea, vomiting or even fainting.

-- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700. -- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 12054700.
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...