But instead of choosing just one today GMA announced it has decided to fulfill the dreams of all four!
Read about the winners' stories and dreams below.
Mark Wilkins, The 'Pudgy Pastor,' Dreams to Rock on Stage With Alice Cooper
Big dreams are all about getting out of your normal routine -- and Mark Wilkins wants to go way, way out.
Mark, the self-proclaimed "pudgy pastor" from Crown Point, Indiana, wishes to fulfil his lifelong dream to rock out with '80s metal legend Alice Cooper.
This year Mark turns 50, but he has never given up on the dream he had as a boy in his room listening to Alice Cooper records in the '70s while the other kids idolized Joe Montana or Lee Majors.
He has every Alice Cooper album and song on his iPod and this summer he will be taking his wife and 21-year-old daughter to their first Alice Cooper concert, his fifth.
"I am a father, a husband and a pastor and I love all those," Mark wrote us. "But being on stage at an Alice Cooper concert would be so out of my life box it would mean the WORLD to me."
In a video submission, Mark's co-workers at Crown Point Methodist Church enthusiastically supported his bid to have his dream come true, joking that at least it would get him out of the office for a few days. At least we think they were joking.
Gail Sylva, Grandmother, Former Nurse and Military Mom, Wants to Dance With 'Dancing With the Stars' Pro
Don't let the headline mislead you. Gail Sylva doesn't just want to dance, she wants to be "swept away by Prince Charming" on the dance floor.
For this 57-year-old grandmother of 11, Prince Charming is Tony Dovolani, the professional dancer from ABC's "Dancing With the Stars" who was last paired with Kate Gosselin.
With her only son about to ship out with the U.S. Marines, the former nurse wants to live the 'Dancing' life, from the makeup and gowns to the quick steps and dips.
"I just can't imagine how wonderful it would be to have the makeover and wear one of those amazing dresses," she said in her submission. "It is just a wonderful thought to experience the grace and fantasy of dancing like one of those women on 'Dancing With the Stars.' I would like to be a star for one day."
Single Mom Jamyce Lee Wants to Bring Some 'Flavor' to 'The View'
When she's not shuttling her three children -- ages 5, 6 and 8 -- to sports practice, working at a home for the mentally disabled, or writing poetry, Jamyce Lee of Kankakee, Illinois, is all about ABC's "The View."
She's watched since the show premiered more than a decade ago and has dreamed of pulling her own chair up to the table.
You could say Lee is a very engaged viewer.
"I argue back and forth like you guys could hear me through the TV," she said in her submission video. "When you talk about something, I'm sitting there going back and forth with you. "
She said she's always been an opinionated person and can't wait to wade into the heated discussions with the ladies of "The View."
"I've had countless dreams of sitting at the table with the women of 'The View' discussing hot topics," she wrote. "Whoopi is honestly the best thing they could've done for 'The View' and I think she is so honest like myself. I feel as though I can bring some flavor to 'The View' so tell the ladies to move over because here I come... Let's get that Emmy!"
Amanda Roberts Grew Up Watching the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders; Now She Wants to Be One
"Let's go Cowboys!"
43-year-old Amanda Roberts has a dream -- and that dream is to dance and cheer alongside the Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders.
"I even went to the extreme of purchasing a uniform," Roberts, a mother of two adult children, said in her submission video.
Roberts, who now lives in Bossier City, Louisiana, is originally from Dayton, Texas. She began to cheer for the team because her mother was a fan.
Roberts watches all of the team's games, watches the Dallas Cowboys' cheerleader reality show, and works out to the Cowboys cheerleader exercise DVDs. She even owns a Dallas Cowboys cheerleader costume -- a treat she bought to surprise her then fiancé, now her husband.
The couple was married last week. Roberts said he is "one of the biggest Cowboy fans" she knows, and attending games was a big part of their courtship.
Roberts said she grew up watching the cheerleaders on television and said to herself, "I can do that!"