Mad Over Health Care Reform, or Something Else?

Scenes of red-faced, finger-pointing, hopping-mad people at health care town hall meetings have been repeated dozens of times across the country this month.

Sen. Arlen Specter, D-Pa., who was berated nose-to-nose by an opponent of the health care reform this week, had to shout over a group to be heard in a 200-person town hall meeting again on Thursday.

"I've had hundreds of town meetings over the course of my career," Specter said after the meeting. "I've been to virtually every county virtually every year, and I've never seen anything like this, or anything near this."

VIDEO: Angry man yells at Senator Specter during town hall meeting on health care.

While members of Congress try to strategize around the uproar for future town meetings, psychologists versed in group dynamics are simply scratching their heads: Is this really about health care, a contagious group fear, or an eruption of smoldering anger over the direction of the country in the past year?

Rep. Mike Coffman, R-Colo., managed to keep the uproar to a minimum at four town hall meetings Wednesday. He started with a presentation of the bill by health care professionals, gave his view in opposition, and opened it up to the crowd with alternating pro-con comment sessions afterwards.

But even after avoiding all but one outburst, Coffman could sense a seething anger.

"I would go speak at events, and the people on the left would be angry at me, but they tended to be more civil -- and the people on the right tended to be angrier," said Coffman. "The ground felt like it was shifting after the stimulus bill and the tea party protests just a little bit."

Although Coffman is against the reform measure and leans to the right politically, he said some people against the heath care bill "would say, 'You people in Congress,' 'You people in Washington.'"

"It was almost like it was an eruption in the distrust in government," Coffman said. "To them, I'm as much as the enemy as anybody else."

Theresa Rose, a specialist in group behavior and a psychologist based Kansas City, Mo., also saw an undercurrent of distress leading up to the fury of the current health care debate.

"In the context of the economy, the stock market, the bitterness of the political battles that have raged," said Rose, "at this time in our country, I think people are often feeling powerless and unable to have an effect."

Is Smoldering Anger, or Group Dynamics Feeding Health Care Screaming Matches?

Robert Lipgar of the American Board of Professional Psychology, and a diplomate in group psychology, agreed it was a smoldering undercurrent of distress lending to the health care ruckus. But he had a different view of the source of unrest.

"My impression is, is that this whole thing is totally irrational. It has very little to do with the issues," said Lipgar.

Lipgar was particularly disturbed that many of the outbursts were connected to myths, such as the rumor that the bill would include "death panels" to decide whether the elderly would live or die.

"People are responding to something that worries them, that frightens them," he said. "People are responding to changes in their lives."

Although the anger may be smoldering, Rose said it might take the anonymity of a large group such as those in town hall meetings to bring out the rage.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
PHOTO: Kanye West accepts the Vanguard Award onstage during the 2015 MTV Video Music Awards at Microsoft Theater on August 30, 2015 in Los Angeles, California.
Christopher Polk/MTV1415/Getty Images
PHOTO: Russian President Vladimir Putin works out at Bocharov Ruchei residence in Sochi, Russia, Aug. 30, 2015.
Russian Presidential Press and Information Office/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images