Poll: Pope John Paul II is Broadly Popular

March 20, 2005 — -- More American Catholics say Pope John Paul II has influenced their moral views, possibly an expression of heightened loyalty to the infirm pontiff. Nearly six in 10, however, also say the next pope should take steps to modernize church policies.

The pope is broadly popular: Sixty-seven percent of all Americans and 87 percent of Catholics view him favorably, about the same as in October 2003, on the 25th anniversary of his papacy. But in a change, 51 percent of Catholics now say John Paul II has influenced their moral views, up from 39 percent then.

That increase has come almost exclusively among practicing Catholics, those who attend church at least a few times a month -- 69 percent say the pope has influenced their moral views, up from 50 percent in 2003. That suggests a rallying of the faithful to his side.

Far fewer non-Catholic Americans, 9 percent, say the pope has influenced their moral views, virtually unchanged from 2003.

John Paul II, who has Parkinson's disease, recently was released from the hospital after undergoing a tracheotomy to ease breathing problems brought on by the flu. The 84-year-old pontiff is convalescing and preparing for Easter Sunday.

In another, slighter change in the pope's direction, 41 percent of Catholics say the next pope should maintain the church's traditional policies, up from 33 percent in 2003. More churchgoing Catholics, but still barely a majority, 51 percent, hold this view.

That leaves 57 percent of Catholics overall (and 48 percent of churchgoing Catholics) who instead say the next pope should change church policies to reflect the attitudes and lifestyles of Catholics today. It was slightly higher, 64 percent, in 2003.

There's a gender gap on this issue. Catholic men are more likely than Catholic women to prefer a pope who would maintain traditional policies.

Like churchgoing Catholics, those who prefer traditional church policies are considerably more likely to say the pope has influenced their personal moral views.

Catholics are more apt to prefer that the next pope come from the developed world rather than from the developing world, but as many say it doesn't matter. Thirty-nine percent would prefer a pope from "the developed world, especially Europe, where almost all previous popes have come from;" 22 percent say he should be from "the developing world, especially South America or Africa, where the church is growing fastest." But 37 percent volunteer that it doesn't make a difference.