Court Rules to Separate Conjoined Twins

A British court has ruled doctors may operate to separate conjoined twin girls — killing one to spare the life of the other.

Three judges of the Court of Appeal ruled unanimously in favor of the separation despite the Roman Catholic parents’ determination to leave the infants’ fate to “God’s will.”

Doctors said the girls, identified only as Jodie and Mary, would die within months if they remained together, but that Jodie could survive on her own.

The surgery means death for baby Mary, who cannot survive without her sister Jodie.

“Though Mary has a right to life, she has little right to be alive. She is alive because and only because — to put it bluntly but nonetheless accurately — she sucks the lifeblood of Jodie and her parasitic living will soon be the cause of Jodie ceasing to live,” said Justice Alan Ward summarizing the judgment.

The case, however, may not end here. The parents will be allowed to appeal to the the House of Lords. Their lawyers say that decision hasn’t been made.

The questions put to the court, “Do we save Jodie by murdering Mary?” is one of the most stark and haunting asked in a court of law.

“Ultimately this is not a court of morals but a court of law,” said Ward. “We had to choose the least detrimental alternative. The scales came down heavily in Jodie’s favor.”

The court said Mary was “designated for death.”

It has been excruciatingly difficult. One’s heart bleeds for the family,” said Ward. “50 percent of the population will agree with the decision — 50 percent will think we have gone potty.”

Jodie and Mary

Jodie and Mary (fictitious names assigned by the court to protect their identities), were born six weeks ago at Saint Mary’s hospital in Manchester.

The parents of the twins, commonly called Siamese twins, traveled to Britain from a Mediterranean country (a court ruling bans identifying the country or the parents) when it became clear the local hospital couldn’t handle the difficult birth.

The two girls were born joined at the abdomen with their heads at opposite ends of their merged bodies and their legs at right angles from each side.

Jodie has a functioning heart, lungs and liver, Mary does not. Doctors say Mary has only a “primitive” brain and is “essentially a parasite” growing at Jodie’s expense.

Physicians originally gave the joined babies only a few months to live if not separated. A second medical opinion suggests they may live a little longer — perhaps a few years — but no long-term survival is likely without separation.

Separation means certain death for Mary. But it is Jodie’s only chance of surviving.

Parents Want God to Decide

The parents of the twins are deeply religious Roman Catholics. They say it is morally and legally wrong to sacrifice one of their children for the other and opposed the operation.

In a submission to the court they said, “We cannot begin to accept or contemplate that one of our children should die to enable the other one to survive. That is not God’s will.”

Their lawyer, John Kitchingman, said they wanted nature to take its course, even if that meant the loss of both children.

“The parents’ view is the children should be allowed to fulfill whatever life expectancy their medical condition permits.”

The children’s doctors disagreed, taking the case to the courts to fight for Jodie’s life.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...