Proposition 8 - California Gay Marriage Headed Towards Supreme Court; One Justice Holds Key

Both sides of California's gay marriage debate say yesterday's ruling by a federal district court judge was only the opening salvo in a legal battle headed for the U.S. Supreme Court. And they've begun honing their arguments to ultimately sway the justices who will have the final say.

U.S. District Court Judge Vaughn Walker's opinion stated that the state's same-sex marriage ban amounts to unconstitutional discrimination and should be immediately struck down. He later issued a stay on the order overturning Proposition 8 to allow supporters of the measure to argue why the ban should remain in effect while they pursue an appeal.

VIDEO: Judge Overturns Prop 8
Judge Overturns Prop 8 Gay Marriage Ban in California

Read Judge Walker's opinion HERE.

"We have other battles aheads of us," said former Bush administration Solicitor General Theodore Olson, who joined former counsel for Al Gore in the 2000 election, David Boies, in opposing Proposition 8.

"Ted and I have a deal -- He is going to get the five justices that were for him in Bush v. Gore and I'm going to get the 4 justices that were with me in Bush v. Gore," Boies joked Wednesday.

Supporters of the California same-sex marriage ban acknowledged Judge Walker's decision was not unexpected and conceded propsects that it will be reversed by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals also looked uncertain. But they are holding out hope for the Supreme Court.

"Let's not lose sight of the fact that this case is headed for the U.S. Supreme Court, where the right of states to define marriage as being between one man and one woman will be affirmed," said Maggie Gallagher, chair of the National Organization for Marriage.

When the case reaches the high court, Justice Anthony Kennedy could become the swing vote on a bench narrowly divided by liberals and conservatives, court observers say.

"It has been Justice Anthony Kennedy at the center of a very sharply polarized four-four court who has consistently been over the years a very strong voice on gay rights," Slate's Dahlia Lithwick pointed out on "Good Morning America" today.

"He's been careful to say, 'This doesn't mean I'm for gay marriage, by the way.' But time after time, he's not just been the fifth vote for anti-discrimination principles, but he's also been a strong vote for things like dignity and humanity and the right to choose your own lifestyle," she said.

Still, how Kennedy or the other eight justices will vote is only speculation. The court does generally have a record of not making rulings that are contrary to majority public opinion.

A California Field poll of registered voters last month found 51 percent support legalizing gay marriage with 42 percent opposed.

But nationwide public views are more narrowly divided, according to the most recent ABC News/Washington Post poll. Forty-seven percent of Americans polled favor gay marriage while 50 percent are opposed.

Judge Walker Calls Marriage Ban an "Artifact"

In his decision Walker sharply criticized the voter-approved Proposition 8 as rooted in "unfounded stereotypes and prejudices."

"Proposition 8 fails to advance any rational basis in singling out gay men and lesbians for denial of a marriage license," wrote Walker in his 136-page decision. "Indeed, the evidence shows Proposition 8 does nothing more than enshrine in the California Constitution the notion that opposite-sex couples are superior to same-sex couples."

Page
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
A Gilchrist county sheriffs car sits at the end of a trailer home where 7 members of a family were slain by their grandfather in Bell, FL, Thursday, Sept., 18, 2014. The grandfather, Don Spirit, pictured, also killed himself.
Phil Sandlin/AP Photo | Gilchrist County Sheriffs Office
PHOTO:
St. Andre Bessette Catholic Church in Ecorse Michigan
PHOTO: Strawberries and cream are a healthy--and delicious--pairing to enjoy after a workout.
EMWestwood Photography/Getty Images
PHOTO: Will Smith and Jada Pinkett Smith arrives at the 86th Annual Academy Awards at Hollywood & Highland Center, March 2, 2014, in Hollywood, Calif.
Steve Granitz/WireImage/Getty Images