Broad Support for Sotomayor's Supreme Court Confirmation

Sotomayor and Supreme Court

Sonia Sotomayor enjoys broad public support for a seat on the U.S. Supreme Court, with large majorities of Americans rejecting the notion that her sex, race or ethnicity play a negative role in how she decides cases as a judge.

Sixty-two percent in this ABC News/Washington Post poll say Sotomayor should be confirmed, among the highest levels of support for a high court nominee in polling data back to Robert Bork in 1987. The only numerically higher was 63 percent initial support for Clarence Thomas, which fell when his nomination turned controversial.

Click here for a PDF with charts and questionnaire.

SEX/ETHNICITY: There's been close scrutiny of a 2001 speech in which Sotomayor said, "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life." Critics say this raises questions of judicial even-handedness; supporters call it a reflection on the benefits of diversity and the fact that life experience shapes judgment.

Results of this poll show support for Sotomayor in two ways. First, 59 percent don't think her sex plays a role in her judicial decisions. Moreover, among those who think it does inform her judgment, 70 percent see that as a good thing. The total – those who see no influence, or a positive one – is 82 percent. (It's virtually identical among women and men.)

The results on ethnicity are somewhat less lopsided; nonetheless 52 percent believe Sotomayor's racial or ethnic background doesn't play a role in her decisions, and of those who think it does, 42 percent call that a good thing. On this, a net total of 68 percent see no influence or a positive one (66 percent of whites, as well as 77 percent of non-whites).

IDEOLOGY and ABORTION: Sotomayor also benefits from a mainstream image. Fifty-five percent say she's "about right" ideologically, about as many as said so about John Roberts and more than Samuel Alito's 44 percent in 2005. Just over a quarter call her too liberal, about as many as called both Roberts and Alito too conservative.

Abortion a Question Mark

Sotomayor's past statements and judicial record leave little hint of her views on abortion, a perennial issue in Supreme Court nominations. It's an issue on which public views are complex, but one that most Americans seem to want left alone. Sixty percent in this poll say that if it came before the court, Sotomayor should vote to uphold Roe v. Wade, about the same results (anywhere from 60 to 65 percent) as for Roberts and Alito four years ago.

Partisans split hard on the issue – 71 percent of Democrats want the law upheld, 54 percent of Republicans want it overturned. Among independents, 61 percent favor it.

Still, Sotomayor's silence on the topic might serve her well. She's supported by 73 percent of those who want Roe v. Wade upheld, but also by a sizable 42 percent of those who oppose the ruling. (For many, it should be noted, a single issue is not determinative.)

Another measure finds Americans' overall opinions on abortion stable: Fifty-five percent say abortion should be legal in most or all cases, while 43 percent believe it should be all or mostly illegal. Those are very near their long-term averages, 56-42 percent, in ABC/Post polls since 1995. Support for legal abortion as usual includes roughly equal numbers of men and women, and is about the same among Catholics as among all adults.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...