Cell Phones on Planes: Why Not?

Has this happened to you? You're on a plane, prepping for the big meeting on your laptop, and a problem arises. You need an answer, fast.

So you reach into your pocket, grab your cell … and it hits you: no calls allowed.

Many of you think that's just terrific, but the "cells-on-planes" landscape is shifting. Just a couple of weeks ago, Mexico OK'ed cell phone calls in its airspace, and Aeromexico immediately said, "We're on it."

Why not? Dubai-based Emirates airline has been offering this service since last year. So has Malaysia Airlines. Plus, the European Union has OK'ed it, and Ryanair says, they're good to go. Still others are working on it.

But in the U.S. cell phone calls in flight are still banned, by both the FAA and the FCC (the FAA worries about the safety of planes, while the FCC worries about the safety of the cellular service). But for how long? Is a domino theory at work here?

It kind of looks that way. But what about our safety?

For more air travel news and insights visit Rick's blog at farecompare.com

Safety and Cell Phones

Let's ask the obvious question: Will a cell phone call interfere with critical airplane functions?

I wish there was a clear-cut answer. Some say, it's likely not a danger, but the FAA still considers it a potential safety issue (according to its "Fact Sheet" on cell phones -- dated 2005).

So why do some airlines allow it? Well, on Emirates, for example, you have to use their onboard picocell network, which isolates the cell communications from the pilot's.

Cell Phones and Hearing

Another safety issue: Can cell phones hurt your hearing? According to Dr. Randy Schnitman, an otolaryngoloist (ear, nose and throat doctor) practicing in Beverly Hills, Calif., cell phones really aren't an audiology medical issue. He says, normal "soft" conversation is about 40 to 50 decibels and he believes many cell conversations fall in that range, though he admits some folks do TALK REAL LOUD on their cells (like the fellow I always refer to as "Yellular").

Dr. Schnitman says this is an issue of social etiquette more than hearing, but added if he was stuck in a middle seat with cell phone yakkers on either side, "It would drive me nuts."

"You'd be better off consulting a psychiatrist about this than an ear doctor," he laughed.

So cell phone users just aren't that noisy; certainly not compared to say, an AC/DC concert which might hit 130 decibels, or even compared to a screaming kid on a plane (90 decibels). And it's no big deal compared to WiFi, either.

Huh? Well, say your seatmate has his laptop out to watch the latest Internet sensation on YouTube and starts laughing it up. Laughter clocks in at about 60 to 65 decibels, which is close to the noise of a hair dryer or vacuum cleaner. But I don't notice people saying "no" to WiFi.

Oh, sure, there was a time when some were dead set against it WiFi on planes -- out of fear of flying elbows, and of boors perusing adult content near innocents. But those concerns have largely melted away.

Today, all the planes of AirTran and Virgin America are WiFi-ed, and American Airlines' Tim Smith says, "By the end of the year, we will have approximately 170 aircraft outfitted with [WiFi], with more aircraft to come next year."

Clearly, a lot of business travelers love having an office in the sky; and a lot of them would love to add phones.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...