Jodi Arias' Attorneys Say They Cannot Proceed in Death Penalty Phase

PHOTO: Jodi Arias in Maricopa County Superior Court, in Phoenix, May 20, 2013.
Share
Copy

The death penalty phase of the Jodi Arias trial was cut short today after Arias' defense attorneys erupted in confrontational arguments with the judge and prosecutor and said they could not continue defending her.

The jury was expecting to hear character testimony from Arias' friends today as part the defense's bid to present mitigating factors to the jury and convince it to sentence her with leniency. But before that could happen, lead defense attorney Kirk Nurmi asked for a mistrial and for permission to withdraw from the case, citing prosecutorial misconduct.

Arias was convicted on May 8 of murdering her ex-boyfriend, Travis Alexander. She now faces the death penalty.

Today, Nurmi told the court that the defense could not go on because one of their mitigating witnesses, Arias' childhood friend Patricia Womack, had been intimidated into not testifying by prosecutor Juan Martinez.

"Miss Womack feels her life is being threatened to an extent she cannot come forward and testify. This is unacceptable," Nurmi said.

"This cannot be a modern-day version of stoning or witch trials," he added, becoming more animated. "When you have a prosecutor that this court allows to personally attack witnesses and counsel, it breeds this sort of environment where intimidating can take place. And this has been happening throughout trial."

See ABC News' Full Coverage of the Jodi Arias Trial

See the 9 Most Shocking Moments of the Jodi Arias Trial

Nurmi has previously asked for two mistrials based on alleged prosecutorial misconduct. Both times, Judge Sherry Stephens denied his motions.

Martinez said that he had merely interviewed Womack about her testimony last week, on May 15, and asked her pointed questions about her drug use and unreported income that could subject her to criminal prosecution. Womack decided to invoke her Fifth Amendment right in response to his questions, Martinez said.

Womack did not appear in court today.

Stephens denied the defense's request for a mistrial, causing Nurmi immediately to move to withdraw from the case. It is the third time he and co-counsel Jennifer Willmott have asked to withdraw.

"Ms. Willmott and I move to withdraw again," Nurmi said today. "We cannot present a full picture [of Arias' life] as incumbent upon us. We cannot fulfill our duties."

When Stephens also denied that request and asked Nurmi to call his first witness for the day, Nurmi said if the court would not rule in the defense's favor on the mistrial or withdrawal motions, there would be no witnesses, leaving only Arias' own statement to the jury before closing arguments.

Nurmi originally told jurors they would hear about Arias' life, her clean criminal record, her quest to better herself and her artwork before they would be asked to rule on her sentence. Without any witnesses or testimony, however, the case wound quickly to its close today.

Stephens adjourned court noting that Arias would give her allocution statement on Tuesday, at 12:30 p.m. ET.

The defense and prosecution both are expected to rest their cases at that time, before the jury goes into deliberations to decide whether to sentence Arias to death or life in prison.

Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
PHOTO: Makeup Artist Uses Chin as Canvas
Laura Jenkinson/Caters News Agency
PHOTO: Left, Texas Governor Rick Perry poses for his official portrait. Right, Perrys mug shot taken on August 19, 2014 after the Governor was indicted on two felony charges for an alleged abuse of power.
Texas State Governors Office | Travis County Sheriffs Office
PHOTO: Robin Williams and Billy Crystal walk the red carpet before a gala on August 4, 2012 in St. Paul, Minnesota.
Adam Bettcher/Getty Images for Starkey Hearing Foundation
PHOTO: Elise Mosca attends ABCs Bachelor In Paradise Premiere Party held at Mixology101 & Planet Dailies, Aug. 4, 2014, in Los Angeles.
Jesse Grant/Getty Images for Leisure Opport