Social Security, Fact vs. Fiction
Feb. 1, 2004 — -- The chatter surrounding Social Security reform heated up last month as President Bush and the administration began making their case for privatizing the nation's retirement benefits system. With the impending retirement of millions of baby boomers, beginning as early as 2008, the Social Security system faces funding deficits over the next 40 years that could force lawmakers to raise taxes, lower benefits or take money out of the general budget to keep pace with the country's aging population.
Saying the time to act is now, Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney have pushed the idea of private investment accounts for younger workers. The president has said the government will not raise payroll taxes to pay for funding shortfalls, noting that by 2018 the system will be paying out more than it takes in, and by 2042 the system will be "bankrupt."
Critics of the president's push for privatization noted that nonpartisan experts from the Congressional Budget Office have said that characterizing Social Security as bankrupt by 2042 is not correct. They point out that the system will always be able to pay benefits if Americans are working and paying payroll taxes. The Social Security trust fund will be depleted between 2040 and 2050, but even then retirees will receive between 70 percent to 80 percent of their promised benefits thanks to the current system's structure.
Administration officials have suggested one way to make up the shortfall is to reduce benefits by changing the way they are calculated. By pegging increases to inflation rather than wages, benefit levels would rise much more slowly.
As the campaign to sell the president's plan begins in earnest, with President Bush expected to focus on his privatization plan in Wednesday night's State of the Union address, ABC News business correspondent Betsy Stark offers a reality check on claims the president is making about the urgency of the problem and whether private accounts are the best way to fix it.
The following quotes are from remarks by the president on Tuesday at his Social Security forum in Washington, D.C.:
"There is plenty of money in the system to take care of those who have retired or near retirement ... But the structure of Social Security is such that you can't avoid the fact that there is a problem, and now's the time to get something done."
The only thing to argue here is whether "now" is the time to act. Actuaries agree that the existing pay-as-you-go formula -- in which revenue collected from the payroll taxes of current workers pays the benefits of current retirees -- will fund benefits at current levels through 2018. After that, there will be too few workers and too many retirees for payroll tax revenue to fully cover retiree benefits. But actuaries estimate there is enough money in the Social Security trust fund to make up the difference through 2042.
