Mutual funds with big losses can still trigger taxes

ByABC News
December 14, 2008, 11:48 PM

— -- You've just lost 35% in your mutual fund. Could things get worse? Of course. Your fund could make a big, taxable capital gains distribution and many are.

The average stock mutual fund has plunged 40%, vs. 38% for the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index with dividends reinvested. But a few funds will be handing a heaping helping of tax liability with their losses:

Fidelity Select Energy Portfolio, down 57% this year, will pay an estimated $2.85 per share in long-term capital gains about 10% of its share price.

Vanguard Health Care fund (investor class) will pay about $8.07 per share in gains, equal to 7.7% of its share price. The fund has fallen 24% this year.

American Funds' New Perspectives fund, down 41%, will make gains payouts of 7% to 9% of its share price. It didn't provide a dollar figure.

How can a losing fund have a long-term gain? Some funds have long-held positions with big gains. If they sell those positions, they may have gains to distribute. Although many funds try to offset gains by selling losers, some don't and that results in real tax pain for shareholders.

Investors in retirement accounts, such as 401(k)s, don't have to worry about gains distributions, because the accounts are tax-deferred or tax-free.

But if you own a fund in a taxable account, a distribution may mean that you'll pay more in taxes. By law, funds have to distribute their long- and short-term gains each year.

Suppose you own 500 shares of a fund that pays $2 per share in long-term capital gains, or $1,000. It also pays 50 cents in short-term gains, or $250. Long-term capital gains taxes are taxed at 15%, so you'd owe the IRS $150. Short-term gains are taxed at your maximum tax rate. In the 25% tax bracket, you'd owe $62.50.

You get the distribution and that tax liability even if you invested in the fund just before the fund's record date the date the fund uses to determine who gets the payout. So you shouldn't invest in a fund between now and the end of the year unless you're certain it has made its distribution.