We asked and you answered. Check out the finalists' recipes below.
The winner will be revealed live Sunday, Nov. 23.
Norma Grubb's Coconut Creme PieCourtesy of Sommerset Hall Café in Dover, Kan.
It may look like a quiet town, but residents of Dover, Kan., tend to wait in lines out the door to eat at the Sommerset Hall Cafe. Everyone's favorite second helping? A slice of one of Norma Grubb's special pies. At 88, the diminutive cook works five mornings a week at a special counter in the cafe's kitchen. Here's the recipe for Norma's best-seller, her Coconut Cream Pie -- a coconut-filled flakey crust, topped with sweet meringue and coconut flakes:
3 cups milk
3 egg yolks (save whites for meringue)
Sprinkle of salt
3/4 cup sugar
4 Tbsp. cornstarch
1 tsp vanilla
Approximately ¼ cup coconut flakes (I don't measure the coconut, Norma says)
Prepared pie crust
Save out a little milk. Put the rest of the milk in a double boiler and heat. In a separate bowl, beat egg yolks. Mix in the milk you saved and salt. Add sugar and stir. Add cornstarch and beat. Stir mixture into hot milk.
Cook on stovetop. Add vanilla and coconut. Put coconut cream filling in baked and cooled pie shell. Make meringue (instructions below).
To Make Meringue:
Beat egg whites until stiff. Add 2 tablespoons sugar
Put on top of pie and sprinkle coconut on top
Put pie in 375 degree oven to brown meringue