Klobuchar homes in on timeline of Barrett’s criticism of ACA and Trump nominating her to federal court in 2017
Continuing the back and forth about the doctrine of severability, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., said she wanted to make clear to the American people it is the position of the Trump administration that the entire Affordable Care Act should be thrown out, not just part of it as Republicans have suggested.
"Health care is on the line. Judge, that's what is on the line in your nomination hearing, which unfortunately has been plopped in the middle of this election," Klobuchar said. "This is a position of the Trump administration filed by the Trump Justice Department. It says that the entire Affordable Care Act must fall."
"If the brief didn't represent the president, he would have them withdraw the brief. Is that right?" Klobuchar asked.
"I believe so, yes," Barrett said.
“I wanted to make that clear to the Chairman, there is this doctrine to separate and try to uphold the statute like maybe pre-existing conditions or keeping kids on your insurance. The position of the Trump administration is to throw the whole thing out," Klobuchar said.
Klobuchar then pressed Barrett on a claim she made Tuesday, when she said she wasn’t aware of Trump’s position to nominate justices that would strike down the Affordable Care Act -- before her Supreme Court nomination.
"There have literally been hundreds of statements by him, by my colleagues, and I just find it hard to understand that you are not aware of the president's statements," Klobuchar said.
"I took Senator Harris's question yesterday to be referring to a specific tweet, maybe the one that you have behind you, about how he wanted to put a justice on the court to replace Obamacare. And I'm definitely aware of that tweet now. And as I said to Senator Harris yesterday, it came up in some of my calls with Democratic senators that brought it up, but I honestly can't remember whether I knew about it before I was nominated or not,” Barrett said.
Klobuchar continued to press Barrett on the timeline of her public criticism of the court upholding the Affordable Care Act in relation to her nomination by Trump to federal court in 2017.
Barrett wrote in law review article published in January 2017 that Chief Justice John Roberts "pushed the Affordable Care Act beyond its plausible meaning to save the statute." She was nominated by Trump to become a judge in May of that year.br/>
"Senator Klobuchar, all of these questions suggest I have animus or that I cut a deal with the president. That isn't what happened," Barrett said.
"My question is simply, were you aware of President Trump's opposition at that time?" Klobuchar asked Barrett of when she wrote the article.
"I have no idea. I suspect if it was published in January, I wrote it before the presidential election. I express I have no amimus or agenda to the Affordable Care Act. You are suggesting that this was an open letter to President Trump. It was not," she said.