ABC News

Six Kids, Eight More: Ethicists Speak Out

California Octuplets Case: Ethicists, Fertility Docs Mull Over Ethics

After learning that the California woman who gave birth to eight babies Monday was already a mother of six, ethicists and fertility experts said that her so-called mega-multiple pregnancy was even more troubling.

Some doctors argue that planting so many embryos is a medical malpractice.

Particulars of the case remain sketchy. Neighbors have told ABC News that the woman is a single mother in her 30s whose first name is Nadya. Hospital staff have refused to release the name of the mother, also declining to comment on whether she had received fertility drugs that have been linked to instances of multiple births.

But the details that have trickled from sources close to the mother have made this already unusual case even more shocking, experts say. The woman's mother, Angela Suleman, told the Los Angeles Times that her daughter had indeed undergone fertility treatments. Moreover, she said that her daughter had an operation last year to have embryos implanted in her uterus, suggesting that an in-vitro fertilization (IVF) procedure may have been involved.

Related

Suleman also has said that when the woman learned she was carrying multiple babies, she opted not to reduce the number of embryos.

University of Pennsylvania bioethicist Arthur Caplan said the new information brings several ethical concerns into play, not the least of which is the question of why a woman who already had six children would have a medical procedure that allowed her to have eight more.

"In my view, it would be irresponsible to treat a woman who was fertile with infertility drugs or techniques," he said. "It is not clear if the six children are hers or adopted or foster kids or what. But if they are hers, then something very unethical may have happened."

And then there is the specific matter of IVF. While fertility experts originally told ABC News that they suspected that the multiple pregnancy was likely the result of drugs designed to make a woman release many eggs at once, increasing her odds of pregnancy after sex, it appears possible now that an actual operation was involved. That would dramatically increase the likelihood of such a risky and costly pregnancy.

NEXT >
Next Story: Losing Heart: Depression Meds Have Risks
Comment & Contribute

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.

More Coverage
Watch Video
1 2 3 4
Health News
Slideshows
1