Planned Parenthood Not the Only Casualty in Texas Defunding


Texas does not prohibit health care providers in the Women's Health Program from referring women to abortion clinics, said state Department of Health and Human Services spokeswoman Linda Edwards Gockel. The provider can tell the patient where she can get an abortion and give her a phone number, for example, but the provider can't help the patient set up her appointment, arrange travel or negotiate a fee reduction, according to the Women's Health Program rules that were finalized in October.

Planned Parenthood has said that 48,000 of the 110,000 patients in the Women's Health Program used its clinics. A survey released Tuesday by the Texas Health and Human Services Commission, in contrast, found that Planned Parenthood served 80,127 women in fiscal 2012, but concluded that the state now has enough eligible providers to serve 147,512 patients and can therefore handle the influx.

Patients displaced by the Planned Parenthood and abortion-affiliated clinic bans can go to to find Women's Health Program-eligible clinics.

"We believe the state misrepresented the level of provider participation," Rogoff said. "They say they have these thousands of providers [to take on the displaced Planned Parenthood patients], but we're listed six times, and we're not taking new patients except for a limited number of teens."

A search for services in ZIP code 78722, part of Austin, yielded four entries for the "Peoples Community Clinic "at a few different addresses plus two more entries at the same address for individual doctors there. But the clinic is just one organization, and it's at capacity, Rogoff said.

The Texas Department of Health and Human Services is aware that the website has some redundancies, but its internal system tracks providers by a single provider number, Edwards Gockel said. The Women's Health Program has 3,500 providers with unique ID numbers, she said.

Patricio Gonzales, CEO of Planned Parenthood Association of Hidalgo County, near the Texas-Mexico border, said he had to lay off half of his staff and close four of the eight Planned Parenthood clinics in the area last year because of the first round of funding cuts in September 2011. Now, he doesn't know what to expect, but said he hopes to continue to serve his remaining 4,900 patients after the Jan. 11 hearing.

"I'm very apprehensive about my clients," Gonzales said. "Who's going to take care of them?"

He said his patients are stressed, asking why they have to stop seeing the doctors who have taken care of them for years because the state doesn't like that their clinic is affiliated with a national organization that supports legal abortion. He said he expects many of them will go without care because of the hassle.

"There's a 1-800 number for people to call so that they can ask somebody else to do the legwork for them," Edwards Gockel said, adding that every caller has been successfully matched with a new provider. About 3,000 people called in November, 2,700 people called in December, and 1,000 people called in the first week of January, she said.

The remaining Hidalgo County Planned Parenthoods will stay open as they try to either help patients find new providers or help them find other programs or grants so that they don't have to leave. The clinics have offered discounted services for patients who are waiting to see whether the ban will be reversed.

Some clinics that aren't losing funding say they're still unhappy with Texas.

The Legacy Community Clinic in Houston was not affected by any of the new family planning rules, but spokesperson Randall Ellis said it has seen an uptick in patients since 2011, when the "well-thought-out and coordinated attack" began with Title X fund rearranging that hurt some clinics.

"We are able to absorb the additional administrative costs and jump through hoops," Ellis said. "When looking at smaller providers in rural areas of the state, they don't have the resources to absorb the changes. Therefore, access is cut off for women in places where there is already limited access."

"For me, it's an issue of priority," he said. "The state has to decide whether they want to make women's health a priority for the state of Texas or not."

-- This embed didnt make it to copy for story id = 18173045.
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...