How We Guess What Others Will Do
May 4 -- The stock market and beauty contests don't seem to belong in the same sentence. It's almost painful to think simultaneously about both WorldCom and Miss Universe. What do faceless corporations and captivating faces have in common?
One obvious answer is that companies and contestants are both frequently judged on superficial grounds. Another is that both companies and contestants sometimes try to hide unsavory aspects of their pasts — Enron's shredding of old documents, for example, or a model's lying about old nude pictures of herself.
John Maynard Keynes, arguably the greatest economist of the 20th century, pointed to a much deeper similarity, that between investors and judges. Specifically, he compared the position of investors in a market to that of reader/judges in newspaper beauty contests, which were very popular in his day. The apparent task of the readers was to pick the five prettiest out of, say, 100 contestants, but their real job was more complicated. The reason was that the newspaper rewarded them with prizes only if they picked the five contestants who received the most votes from the other readers.
That is, they had to pick the contestants that they thought were the most likely to be picked by the other readers, and the other readers had to try to do the same. They were not to give undue weight to their own taste. Instead they had to anticipate, in Keynes' words, "what average opinion expects the average opinion to be" (or, worse, anticipate what the average opinion expects the average opinion expects the average opinion to be).
A Simple Game
Countless situations — not just the stock market — require that we anticipate the actions of many other people, but our understanding of how we do this is hazy, to say the least. Whether in politics, war, business, or everyday life, how group consensus develops and sometimes suddenly changes remains intuitive and unformalized.
Various mathematical tools ranging from network theory to fractals are useful, but a simple game I discuss in my forthcoming book, A Mathematician Plays the Stock Market, is also relevant. In the game, people in a group are each asked to choose a number between 0 and 100. Furthermore, they're directed to pick the number that they think will be closest to 80 percent of the average number chosen by the group. The person who comes closest to this value will receive $1,000 for his or her efforts. Don't go on until you decide what number you would pick.
Related Stories
ABC News Live