The Math of Confused Eyewitnesses

This is not a trivial problem, since it's estimated that almost 80,000 people annually become criminal defendants after being picked out of a lineup by eyewitnesses.

Calculating the Accuracy of a Witness

Using Bayes' Theorem, Wells points out that the base rate likelihood — the initial probability that a suspect is the culprit — greatly affects the subsequent likelihood — the probability that he is the culprit given that he has been picked out of a lineup. If the base rate likelihood is small, eyewitness' identifications need to be almost certain to ensure the subsequent probability is reasonably high. In the penny problem discussed above, the base rate likelihood of picking the culprit is 33 percent, the subsequent likelihood 63 percent.

Another useful notion that Wells explores is the information gain from eyewitness identification. This is the difference between the subsequent likelihood that he is the culprit given he's been identified as such and the base rate likelihood that he is.

Again considering the biased penny to be a culprit of sorts, we conclude the information gain from seeing a penny flipped three times and landing heads all three times is the difference between the probability the penny is the culprit given that it's landed heads three times (63 percent) and the initial probability the penny is the culprit (33 percent). The information gain is thus 30 percent.

There are, of course, many other nuances and variations but the bottom line is that the eyewitness testimony on which people are convicted is sometimes not worth three cents.

Professor of mathematics at Temple University, John Allen Paulos is the author of several best-selling books, including Innumeracy and A Mathematician Reads the Newspaper. His Who’s Counting? column on appears on the first day of every month.

  • 1
  • |
  • 2
Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...
See It, Share It
PHOTO: Firefighters rescue a woman who got stuck in a chimney in Thousand Oaks, Calif.
Ventura County Fire Department
PHOTO: Apple Pay is demonstrated at Apple headquarters on Oct. 16, 2014 in Cupertino, Calif.
Marcio Jose Sanchez/AP Photo
PHOTO: Up in Ash: Mount Sinabung Erupting
Tibt Nangin/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images
PHOTO: Defendant Jodi Arias testifies about killing Travis Alexander in 2008 during her murder trial in Phoenix, Feb. 20, 2013.
Charlie Leight/The Arizona Republic/AP Photo
PHOTO: Kim Kardashian, Kanye West, their daughter North West and Delphine Arnault attend the Givenchy show as part of the Paris Fashion Week Womenswear Spring/Summer 2015, Sept. 28, 2014 in Paris.
Bertrand Rindoff Petroff/French Select/Getty Images