Flesh-Eating Disease: Severe Pain Leads Symptoms

PHOTO: Doug Murphy, left, with his daughter Macy, nearly lost his right leg two years ago to flesh-eating bacteria after a leaky trash bag brushed his ankle during cleanup after her school picnic.PlayCourtesy Cassidy Cline
WATCH Flesh-Eating Bacteria Victim's Spirits High

When a leaky trash bag brushed his ankle during cleanup at his daughter's kindergarten class picnic two years ago, Doug Murphy initially thought nothing of it. But bacteria that entered through his ankle created a flesh-eating infection that nearly cost him his right leg – and his life.

By the next morning, he noticed "a black mark, about the size of a quarter" that he dismissed as a spider bite, located where fluid from the leaky bag had seeped through his sock. By the second morning, his temperature was 105, he couldn't stand and the black area had expanded to "the size of a pineapple. You would be scared it if was you," Murphy recalled Wednesday.

At a nearby emergency room, a savvy infectious disease specialist who examined him "thought it might be necrotizing fasciitis," better known as a flesh-eating bacterial infection. That's about the last thing Murphy remembers. He was admitted to intensive care and placed on powerful antibiotics. His kidneys began shutting down, his blood pressure sank and his temperature soared to 107.7 as the infection spread beyond the leg and throughout his bloodstream, causing sepsis. He began hallucinating and was convinced "I was invited to Brad and Angie's secret wedding in L.A."

His temperature hovered at 107.7 for days, breaking just as doctors were planning to amputate his right leg. Murphy remained hospitalized a total of six weeks before he was released with a gaping leg wound that took a year to heal. The leg, he says, looked "like you poured acid on it and it dissolved down like in [the movie] 'Alien.'"

Today, the 45-year-old father of two from Brooklyn, N.Y., says his scarred right leg doesn't hold him back as an operator of academic summer camps, or as singer-songwriter for his country-rock band. However, the infection badly damaged lymph nodes in the leg, which swells each day and must be elevated in the evenings.

Murphy was infected with Group A streptococcus, which can live harmlessly on the skin or cause a strep throat, but is also the leading cause of flesh-eating bacterial infections. They also can be caused by several other organisms, including aeromonas hydrophila, staphylococcus aureus and vibrio vulnificus. Aimee Copeland, a 24-year-old Georgia student, lost her leg almost two weeks ago to an aeromonas infection contracted in a zip line accident, and Lana Kuykendall, a paramedic from South Carolina, continues to battle a flesh-eating infection that developed soon after she delivered twins.

Murphy is among survivors who have shared their stories with the National Necrotizing Fasciitis Foundation, founded by Donna Batdorff of Grand Rapids, Mich., and Jacqueline Roemmele of Watchung, N.J., who lived through similar infections and now try to help fellow survivors and patients navigate through the care and complications associated with a condition that kills one in four patients, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Tips:Treat Small Cuts, Seek Attention for Disproportionate Pain

Batdorff and Roemmele heard from "tens of thousands" of survivors worldwide and are aware of at least 25 cases in which people were sickened more than once. Batdorff developed her infection while skiing in Colorado in 1996 but ignored escalating symptoms. She ended up unconscious in a hospital and woke up to her sister telling her that doctors had amputated parts of the fingers of her right hand.

One of the tricky things about necrotizing fasciitis, she said, is that "sometimes there's terrible, ugly, bulbous nasty blisters – you know there is something really wrong. But in my case, there was nothing that was really visual like that. No alarming visual signs."

Roemmele became sick in 1994 after an abdominal hernia repair that led to two hospitalizations. The ordeal left her with a hip that even today looks as if she suffered "a shark bite" as well as residual nerve damage in her fingers.

Batdorff says there are several practical considerations that can improve the odds of surviving the disease, starting with quick attention to what seem like minor skin openings: "When you get that paper cut, when you cut yourself a tiny bit with a knife, when a staple punctures your finger, when you prick your finger with a rose thorn -- the smallest, tiniest opening is an opening that bacteria can get into-- and it can kill you," she said. "The preventive is don't ignore these things. Go and wash it, put antibacterial ointment on it and cover it."

Second, she said, is recognizing that these infections can send out warning signs, including "pain that's disproportionate to the size and scope of the injury. And it's not just a little bit of pain, it's pain like you've never felt before." Other signs can be flulike symptoms, lethargy and even feeling delirious or buzzy. "That is the time when you need to get to the doctor. Just get to the emergency room."

Once in the emergency room, speak up. The symptoms often are mistaken for the flu, for brown recluse spider bites and "more people than I can ever begin to tell you about have been sent home to take antibiotics, or rest, or drink fluids ... and they come back the next day. Sometimes people are sent home a couple of times." Such patients often die "before someone figures out what's wrong with them."

"The problem is that necrotizing fasciitis behaves like a wolf in sheep's clothing," Roemmele said. "It masks itself as many things. The initial diagnostic tests like MRI or CT scan often won't show anything."

She said that many doctors have a mantra: "If you hear hooves outside your window, chances are it's a horse and not a zebra," meaning that you should first consider the obvious explanation. "Our point is, physicians need to be trained to look at necrotizing fasciitis as a horse and not a zebra."

If you suspect the disease, ask doctors to rule it out. Batdorff cited the case of "a gentleman whose wife said to the emergency room staff, ''could this be the flesh-eating bacteria?' They said no. And it was. And he died."