ANALYSIS: Spain should find a way not to smash Catalonia's romantic movement for independence

PHOTO: A man wearing a Spanish flag walks along a street ahead of a rally against Catalonias declaration of independence, in Barcelona, Spain, Oct. 29, 2017.PlaySanti Palacios/AP
WATCH More than 1 million people march in Barcelona to support a unified Spain

A massive, joyous demonstration of Spanish patriotism filled the streets of Barcelona.

Interested in Spain?

Add Spain as an interest to stay up to date on the latest Spain news, video, and analysis from ABC News.
Add Interest

It was a glorious sight.

More than a million people -- 1.3 million according to police estimates -- took part.

Countless flags and banners waved above the crowd in the brilliant sunshine, transforming the broad avenues of the city into rivers of riotous color.

Songs and cheers and chants filled the air. “Viva Catalonia! Viva Espana!”

PHOTO: Pro-unity supporters take part in a demonstration in central Barcelona, Spain, Oct. 29, 2017. Rafael Marchante/Reuters
Pro-unity supporters take part in a demonstration in central Barcelona, Spain, Oct. 29, 2017.

These are the Catalonians who don't want independence. They love being Spaniards. And they feel their beloved homeland has been hijacked by the “independentistas.”

So they showed their strength. And they have the full backing of the Spanish government.

But, there are two rival governments here now, each claiming to be the legitimate authority.

There’s the local government, which declared independence on Friday and insists it is now the representative of a sovereign state, Catalonia.

And there is the national government of Spain in Madrid, which dissolved that local government, fired its officials, threatened to arrest its leaders, and called for new elections on December 21st.

As of now, both sides have forsworn the use of force.

So it’s a standoff.

PHOTO: Pro-unity supporters take part in a demonstration in central Barcelona, Spain, Oct. 29, 2017. Jon Nazca/Reuters
Pro-unity supporters take part in a demonstration in central Barcelona, Spain, Oct. 29, 2017.

Spain’s strategy is to slowly assert control over the region, encourage those here who wish to remain in Spain, who may represent a majority, and watch while the international community refuses to recognize Catalonia’s declaration of independence, and the business community freaks out.

Already, tourism to Catalonia is sagging. And thousands of businesses have moved their headquarters out of Barcelona, fleeing the new instability and uncertainty in what has been one of the most prosperous communities in all of Europe.

People here know they risk killing the goose that’s laid so many golden eggs.

Some in the independence camp seem to know how long the odds are against them. One official in the local government was quoted saying, “We’ve advanced the cause, for the next guys that come after us.”

But the endgame could still get violent. Feelings are running very high, and the honor of the independence movement is now at stake.

What’s needed is some sign that the government of Spain will do more than just smash this romantic movement which seeks to build a new nation, and instead offer a compromise that might address some of the grievances that fueled that dream in the first place.

PHOTO: Nationalist supporters gesture at police outside the Catalan Government building, the Palau de la Generalitat following a pro-unity protest on Oct. 29, 2017 in Barcelona, Spain. Jack Taylor/Getty Images
Nationalist supporters gesture at police outside the Catalan Government building, the Palau de la Generalitat following a pro-unity protest on Oct. 29, 2017 in Barcelona, Spain.

But so far, Spain has only offered unconditional surrender.

As the crisis deepens, the rest of Europe waits and watches, worried.

European Council President Donald Tusk spoke for many when he said that the Spanish government should use “the force of argument, not the argument of force” to bring prodigal Catalonia back into the fold.

We shall see.