Doctor Arrested as Suspect in 4 Unsolved Nebraska Murders

Dr. Anthony Garcia was fired from the university the victims were connected to.

July 16, 2013 — -- An Indiana doctor has been arrested on suspicion of four murders in Nebraska that occurred in 2008 and 2013.

All four people were connected to Creighton University's medical school, from which the suspect was fired more than a decade ago.

Dr. Anthony Garcia, 40, was arrested by Illinois State Police on Monday when he was driving near the Indiana border, according to police. Garcia has been living in Terre Haute, Ind.

Garcia was pulled over in a traffic stop and arrested without incident, police said. He showed signs of alcohol intoxication and had a .45 caliber handgun with him, Omaha Police Chief Todd Schmaderer said at a news conference on Monday.

"The task force has been monitoring Dr. Garcia's movement for a period of time," Schmaderer said.

"In 2008, the murders of Shirlee Sherman and Thomas Hunter caused great concern for the Omaha community," Schmaderer said. "In May 2013, the murders of Dr. [Roger Brumback] and Mary Brumback further placed the Omaha community and especially the Creighton pathology department on considerable edge."

Authorities believe Garcia is responsible for a 2008 Omaha home invasion where Sherman and 11-year-old Thomas were stabbed to death. Thomas was the son of Creighton pathology department professor Dr. William Hunter and Sherman was the family housekeeper, according to police.

In May, Creighton pathology professor Dr. Roger Brumback was shot to death and his wife Mary Brumback was fatally stabbed, police said.

Garcia was a resident in the Creighton pathology department from July 2000 to June 2001.

"[Garcia's] employment ended when he was terminated by Dr. Hunter and Dr. Brumback," Schmaderer said. "We do know why he was terminated. The specifics I won't say here today. But it was for a form of erratic behavior."

The chief said the announcement of the arrest can provide a "sense of closure" to the families, university and community that were shaken by both sets of murders.

The Brumback children today expressed their gratitude toward their local community and law enforcement in a statement released through Crieghton University.

"We would like to express our heartfelt appreciation for all of the time and energy of all law enforcement officers involved in this investigation and their continued work in ensuring any guilty party is brought to justice," the statement said. "They have given part of their lives to provide our family with some degree of closure and for that, we are grateful."

Members of the Hunter family did not respond to a request for comment and authorities did not know if Garcia has retained an attorney.

Creighton University would not comment further on the circumstances surrounding Garcia's termination but released a statement from the university's president, the Rev. Tim Lannon.

"We continue to keep those affected by these events in our thoughts and prayers," Lannon said. "And we continue to pray for all of the special task force members still executing search warrants throughout the country."

Public records show that Garcia has held medical licenses in California, Illinois and Indiana since 2003, according to ABC's Indianapolis affiliate WRTV.

Schmaderer said task forces across the country are still searching several places where Garcia lived and worked.

"It is imperative that I do not divulge too much of the evidence that law enforcement has on this case because it is ongoing," he said. "At this point in our investigation, we are led to believe that he committed the murders alone and we are investigating the history of Dr. Garcia."

Garcia appeared in court this morning, but the hearing was postponed until Wednesday because Garcia did not yet have an attorney with him, according to the Omaha World-Herald.

Top Stories

Top Stories

Top Stories

Top Stories

ABC News Live

ABC News Live

24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events