JetBlue Sued: Underwear Altercation Humiliates Malinda Knowles

Malinda Knowles claims JetBlue kicked her off flight over underwear dispute.

ByABC News
July 26, 2011, 9:27 AM

July 26, 2011— -- A financial consultant says she was kicked off her JetBlue flight after a supervisor demanded to know if she was wearing underwear, then allegedly stuck his walkie-talkie between her legs. Malinda Knowles, 27, is now suing JetBlue, the supervisor and the flight captain, seeking an unspecified amount for assault and battery, and emotional distress.

"It's not easy for me to talk about," Knowles said.

Knowles, 27, had boarded a JetBlue flight departing New York's LaGuardia Airport for West Palm Beach, Fla., where her family lives. She flies to Florida several times a year, she said.

That morning in July 2010, she left her home in Harlem at 4 a.m. to catch the 6 a.m. flight. She was wearing a pair of shorts, a large T-shirt (and yes, underwear), an outfit she says she selected, in part, because it was more than 90 degrees outside.

Everyone had boarded the plane, and Knowles was in her seat sipping orange juice when she said JetBlue supervisor Victor Rodriguez approached her, demanding to know "with a smirk" if she was wearing underwear.

"He just came up to me and asked me … basically to show him what I had on, which would have required me moving the tray table and pretty much opening my legs," she said. "I didn't feel comfortable doing that."

Knowles said she eventually lifted her tray table and then, Rodriguez -- who was holding a walkie-talkie -- allegedly "stuck the antennae in her crotch," between her legs, to see what she had on underneath her T-shirt, Knowles' attorney, Brian Dratch, told

Knowles told she had never seen Rodriguez before, and had passed through all the security checkpoints at LaGuardia without any problem.

Rodriguez allegedly called Port Authority police, and "had me escorted off of the flight in front of everyone," she said.

They took her to the loading bridge, the passageway between the airport terminal and the plane, according to Knowles.

The police soon observed, "Oh, she has shorts on," Knowles said.

Rodriguez, who is still working for JetBlue, declined to comment and referred to his lawyer, JetBlue attorney Michael Carbone, who also declined comment because of the pending litigation.

It's unclear, Dratch said, what Rodriguez's motive was, or even why he was on the plane. Dratch told Rodriguez works at the ticket counter.

Knowles said the police told her they needed to file a report, but when she asked them why, they didn't give a reason. "So they have me go get my driver's license. I walk back on, and everyone is staring at me. They think maybe I'm a terrorist or something."

Police Report Says Captain Called Malinda Knowles 'Unruly'

According to the police report, obtained by, a flight attendant noted Knowles was wearing a T-shirt that came down to her "upper thighs, with no indication that any clothing was underneath."

The report says the captain of the flight stated "she was unruly and asked her to exit," at which point Knowles "voluntarily exited the aircraft and was rebooked on a later flight."

Knowles, who had not read the report before speaking to ABC News, found the details bewildering.

"I never saw the captain," Knowles told, adding she had also never interacted with a flight attendant.

After she was questioned by Rodriguez in the loading bridge, and showed the police her driver's license, she settled back into her seat.

"They told me everything was fine -- go sit down," she said.

But Rodriguez allegedly returned another time, with the police.

"He said there was an issue with my shorts," Knowles said, explaining that at this point the plane had already been delayed at least half an hour. "Everyone [on the plane] was very upset, and very annoyed."

She said Rodriguez then told her "the captain doesn't want to fly you today and we need to remove you from the flight."

Next, police allegedly escorted her to the JetBlue ticket counter.