Staff members at Bahamas resort arrested for drugging, assaulting 2 American women: Police

Two men have been arrested and an investigation is ongoing.

February 8, 2024, 8:11 PM

Two resort staffers were arrested in the Bahamas after a pair of American women on vacation said they were drugged and assaulted, according to the Royal Bahamas Police Force.

Amber Sherer and Dongayla Dobson went on vacation without their kids for the first time earlier this month, taking a Carnival cruise to the Bahamas. On the last day of their trip, the cruise stopped on Grand Bahama Island and the two women went to a resort that was recommended by the cruise company, the women said.

Sherer and Dobson said resort staff offered them a two-for-one drink -- which they accepted -- and almost immediately began feeling ill.

"After the first drink, we had to get out of the ocean, because we noticed that it was just hitting so hard. I just felt so out of it," Dobson said in an interview that aired Thursday on "Good Morning America."

PHOTO: Beach Resort on Grand Bahama Island.
Beach Resort on Grand Bahama Island.
Denistangneyjr/Getty Images

The two women said they lost consciousness and were assaulted by two resort staff members. The two mothers said they had bruises on their legs and tested positive for various drugs.

"I vaguely remember glimpses of his face. I don't remember all of it," Dobson said. "I don't remember everything, but I remembered enough of that -- he was a staff worker, and he had a goatee, and he was a local -- that the resort security was able to pull the footage and identify them right then and there."

The Royal Bahamas Police Force said in a statement that they "recognize the seriousness of such matters and handle them with the highest level of professionalism, privacy and sensitivity."

PHOTO: Carnival Cruise ships Liberty and Elation are seen in Nassau, Bahamas, April 29, 2019.
Carnival Cruise ships Liberty and Elation are seen in Nassau, Bahamas, April 29, 2019.
Daniel Slim/AFP via Getty Images/FILE

Police said preliminary reports indicate that the incident occurred on Feb. 4, shortly after noon at a Central Grand Bahama beach. Police began their investigation upon learning of the incident and arrested two men -- a 54-year-old man from Eight Mile Rock and a 40-year-old man from South Bahamia.

Officers later boarded the ship and provided a sexual assault kit, hospital form from the ship's medical doctor and obtained the women's statements, police said.

The Royal Bahamas Police Force is working with the FBI on the investigation.

PHOTO: Amber Shearer and Dongayla Dobson speak to Good Morning America, Feb. 8, 2024.
Amber Shearer and Dongayla Dobson speak to Good Morning America, Feb. 8, 2024.
Good Morning America

"Through the FBI's Legal Attaché office in Nassau, we have strong, established relationships and stand ready to assist in any way the Bahamian government may request. We refer you to Royal Bahamas Police Force, which is leading the investigation, for any comment on this matter," the FBI said in a statement.

In a statement to ABC News, the Pirates Cove Zipline and Water Park said, in part, "we are very concerned about the allegations made and will continue to cooperate with authorities to faithfully resolve the issue" and noted that while the police investigation is ongoing, they have "terminated the employment of the two accused."

"At Pirates Cove, the safety of our guests and team members is always paramount. We regret that our guests experienced this incident, and we remain steadfast in our commitment to aid police in the collection of evidence in response to these allegations, including providing Police access to video from the sixteen cameras around the beach facility where the assault of the two guests allegedly occurred," Pirates Cove said in the statement.

"We are very concerned about the allegations made and will continue to cooperate with authorities to faithfully resolve the issue," the statement said.

Carnival Cruises said in a statement that they are providing their full cooperation to authorities.

"While ashore in Freeport, Bahamas, on an independent shore excursion, two guests on Carnival Elation reported to Bahamian Police that they were sexually assaulted at a local beach," Carnival Cruises told ABC News in a statement. "Our onboard care team provided support for the two guests as they sailed back to Jacksonville. Bahamian Police are investigating the matter and Carnival is providing our full cooperation."

The U.S. State Department issued a Level 2 travel advisory for the Bahamas in January, warning that there has been an increase in homicides and sexual violence.

The two mothers told ABC News that the arrests are not enough and are demanding justice.

Editor's Note: This article has been updated to reflect a statement received by ABC News from the Pirates Cove Zipline and Water Park.