Maryland, West Virginia and Nebraska primaries 2024: Alsobrooks beats Trone, GOP incumbents survive

538 tracked over 10 competitive primaries for Senate, House and governor.

Tuesday, May 14 was another busy primary day, as voters in three states decided who would be on their general election ballots this fall. In Maryland, Democrats nominated women in two safely Democratic congressional seats, including Angela Alsobrooks, who is poised to become only the third Black woman ever elected to the Senate. In West Virginia and Nebraska, incumbent Republican representatives fended off far-right challengers.

538 reporters and contributors broke down the election results as they came in with live updates, analysis and commentary. Read our full live blog below.


0

Maryland's 6th District offers Republicans their best shot at flipping a seat

Biden would've carried Maryland's 6th District by only about 10 percentage points in 2020, according to Daily Kos Elections are former state delegates: Neil Parrott, who lost to Trone in 2020 and 2022, and Dan Cox, who lost as the GOP nominee in Maryland's 2022 gubernatorial contest. Parrott has raised $271,000, while Cox has only brought in $123,000. But Cox may be buoyed by his indefatigable support for Trump's unfounded claims that Biden's 2020 victory was illegitimate — a view that around two-thirds of Republicans still subscribe to nationally.

Four other candidates may also have a shot here. Former Naval fighter pilot Tom Royals leads the field in fundraising with $521,000, Air Force veteran Mariela Roca has brought in $274,000 and retired state trooper Chris Hyser has raised $155,000 and has received some outside spending support. Lastly, former state Del. Brenda Thiam is another familiar face for local Republicans, although she's only raised about $50,000.

—Geoffrey Skelley, 538


Democrats in Maryland's 6th District can go for a familiar name or a fresh face

Trone's Senate campaign left Maryland's 6th District in the western part of the state with no incumbent. On the Democratic side, former Commerce Department official April McClain Delaney and state Del. Joe Vogel look like the front-runners for the Democratic nod. McClain Delaney's name may sound familiar: Her husband, former Rep. John Delaney, represented the old version of this district for three terms. Running on her connections to Biden and work to keep kids safe online, McClain Delaney has self-funded a bit more than half of the $1.9 million she's raised, and she has some high-profile endorsements, including from The Washington Post.

Meanwhile, Vogel is a 27-year-old Latino legislator who is also gay and Jewish. He has raised $687,000 and enjoys endorsements from the powerful state teachers union and the LGBTQ+ Victory Fund. He's also received nearly $400,000 in outside spending help from the pro-LGBTQ Equality PAC, according to OpenSecrets. Competing surveys show a close race: A late April Public Policy Polling survey for McClain Delaney's campaign gave her a 37-percent-to-24-percent lead.

—Geoffrey Skelley, 538


AIPAC changes the course of Maryland's 3rd District primary

As Geoffrey alluded to, the unexpected entrance of AIPAC's super PAC, United Democracy Project, into the Democratic primary in Maryland's 3rd District is one of the biggest stories in Maryland politics right now. The pro-Israel group arguably upended the race with its significant spending (More than $4.2 million as of Friday) on behalf of Elfreth, elevating her from a pack of a half-dozen current and former elected officials — three state delegates, another state senator and a prominent labor attorney — to be the top challenger against Dunn.

UDP has lapped the entire field in spending on TV, allowing Elfreth to go punch-for-punch against Dunn even though he has dominated fundraising (although, after UDP entered the race, Elfreth's own fundraising picked up too). Lam had been keeping pace with Elfreth in fundraising until UDP got involved, but he simply hasn't been able to compete in the ad wars and now lags in polling.

What makes UDP's involvement particularly striking is that neither Elfreth nor Dunn are focused on Israel issues or appear to have much daylight between them on the topic. Dunn even produced a white paper arguing for unconditional support for Israel and its right to defend itself. That's a difference from some other races UDP has gotten into, including a very expensive primary in Maryland's 4th District in 2022 and the recent Republican primary in Indiana's 8th District, both of which featured candidates with records that frustrated the pro-Israel group.

UDP's stated reason for spending here, according to the Huffington Post, was actually to stop John Morse, a labor attorney who has been critical of the Israeli government since Oct. 7. But that explanation has never really held water among Maryland political observers for the simple reason that, despite an endorsement from Sen. Bernie Sanders and some progressive backing, Morse has never been a factor in the race. He's raised just $123,000 — a fraction of Elfreth's haul, let alone Dunn's — and has never polled higher than 3 percent. If that's the real reason, it's not a wildly compelling one.

Some Dunn allies believe the real reason is donor maintenance on UDP's part — that one or a handful of the group's donors have beef with Dunn unrelated to Israel and are using UDP as a conduit to block him. It's speculation, but it's as good a theory as any that UDP has offered itself, especially since the group continued to pour money into the district long after it was clear Morse was destined to be an also-ran.

Jacob Rubashkin, Inside Elections


An expensive Democratic primary in Maryland's 3rd District

Running between Washington, D.C., and Baltimore, the solidly blue 3rd District sits open following the retirement of Democratic Rep. John Sarbanes. A deluge of money has flooded the contest, mainly in support of former Capitol Hill police officer Harry Dunn and state Sen. Sarah Elfreth, although state Sen. Clarence Lam may have an outside shot at winning.

Dunn became prominent after he testified before Congress in July 2021 about defending the Capitol against insurrectionists on Jan. 6, 2021, later receiving a Presidential Citizens Medal for his service. Notably, Dunn's campaign launch video featured him speaking to camera while walking through a recreation of the events of Jan. 6. His announcement precipitated a money monsoon: Dunn raised more without self-funding in the first quarter of 2024 ($3.8 million) than any other non-incumbent House candidate. Overall, he's raised $4.6 million, which has allowed him to run ads emphasizing his background, an endorsement from Rep. Nancy Pelosi and his goal to protect democracy. Dunn has loose ties to the 3rd District area, however, as he lives in Montgomery County closer to the nation's capital.

By comparison, Elfreth likely started out better-known, as around 60 percent of her Annapolis-based state Senate seat lies in the 3rd District, according to Daily Kos Elections. She's raised about $1.5 million, but Elfreth has also received $4.2 million in outside spending support from United Democracy Project, the bipartisan American Israel Public Affairs Committee's super PAC. Despite AIPAC's pro-Israel policy focus, UDP's ads have emphasized Elfreth's effectiveness as a legislator and work to protect abortion rights. For his part, Lam has raised $736,000, but he sat in third with 8 percent in a late April survey for Dunn's campaign conducted by Upswing Research, while Dunn narrowly led Elfreth 22 percent to 18 percent.

—Geoffrey Skelley, 538


Final thought: TV advertising and diminishing marginal returns

Money can buy you a lot of things, but it's not all-powerful. Trone found that out the hard way tonight when he hit a ceiling of about 42 percent of the vote (with 61 percent of the expected vote reporting), despite spending untold millions. If Trone had spent $30 million less, I'm not sure he would have done all that much worse. If he had spent $60 million less, he probably wouldn't have registered at all.

It was obvious that money was a big part of victories elsewhere in the state and country. In Maryland's 3rd District, Elfreth was able to ride a wave of outside support to a comfortable but tough projected win over Dunn — without that money, I'm not sure she would have succeeded. And the third-place finisher, Lam, was not coincidentally the only other candidate to go on TV. In Maryland's 6th District, the only two Democrats with money to go on TV were also the ones to place in double digits, Delaney and Vogel, and the bigger spender won more votes. And in West Virginia's 2nd District and Nebraska's 2nd District, big spending by incumbent GOP representatives and their outside allies ultimately staved off underfunded challenges from right-wing opponents.

Anyway, my biggest takeaway is that Maryland has something to offer for everyone! And our flag is the best in the nation. With that: Good night.

—Jacob Rubashkin, Inside Elections