Debate Verdict: John McCain, Barack Obama Exchange Blows, No Knockouts

Oct. 8, 2008— -- Barack Obama and John McCain had their most intense debate yet Tuesday night, but when it was over little had changed in their increasingly bitter contest for the White House.

The two men tangled over the economy, health care, taxes, energy, Iran and their temperaments during their 90-minute town hall style debate in Nashville, Tenn.

While each candidate got in clean shots, none of the blows were significant enough to alter the direction of the race, which has Obama building a growing lead over McCain in most polls.

McCain Needed 'Game Changer' in Second Debate

The pressure was on McCain when the two men met in the second of three scheduled debates to produce a "game changer," something that would alter the dynamic of the race and reverse his slide in the polls.

"There was nothing that Sen. McCain said last night that people are going to be talking about today... that's going to change the nature of this race," George Stephanopoulos, ABC News' senior Washington correspondent, told "Good Morning America" the day after the debate.

"He tried to put Sen. Obama on the defensive on taxes, on spending. But it didn't really seem to stick."

Watch Highlights From the Debate By Clicking Here and Watch 'World News' at 6:30 p.m. ET Wednesday for Charles Gibson's Interview With Barack Obama

One thing that people were talking about, however, was McCain's dismissive reference to Obama as "that one" after asking a question about which candidate voted for an energy bill that was "loaded with goodies."

Obama, who talked about his determination to kill Osama bin Laden in Pakistan if necessary, "showed toughness on foreign policy" and made a dramatic point about health care when he talked about his mother dying of cancer at the age of 53 and spending her last month in the hospital battling insurance companies.

Both campaigns came out of the debate with fresh TV ads.

Obama's new attack ad is titled "Taketh" and includes a moment in the debate in which Obama argues that McCain's plan to give Americans a $5,000 tax deduction to buy health care would be financed by taxing health care benefits. "So what one hand giveth, the other hand taketh away," Obama says.

McCain's attack ad tags Obama as the Senate's most liberal member and complains that Obama defends himself by accusing other people of lying.

The two rivals have 26 more days and one more debate before Election Day.

"His back is really up against the wall," Stephanopoulos said, referring to McCain.

"He's getting outspent two to one, three to one in battleground states. He's behind in every battleground state that matters right now," he said.

No Knockouts for McCain, Obama in 2nd Presidential Debate

McCain opened the debate Tuesday night by offering a new proposal aimed at helping struggling homeowners to avoid foreclosure.

McCain said he would cut taxes for all Americans and proposed a new policy in which the secretary of the Treasury would "buy up bad home loan mortgages."

The proposal would cost about $300 billion, which the campaign said would come out of the $700 billion financial bailout package passed by Congress last week, according to a fact sheet distributed by the McCain campaign.

"Let people be able to make those payments and stay in those homes," McCain said. "Is it expensive? Yes. But until we stabilize, we're never going to be able to turn around and fix jobs. We got to bring trust and confidence to America, and I know how to do that."

Though the candidates sparred on a wide range of issues including foreign policy and health care, the first question handled by the candidates echoed the seminal question in the minds of American voters, from Joe Six-Packs to soccer moms: What does the economic crisis mean to average Americans?

Both made a point to portray themselves as reformers who believe strong leadership and government involvement is necessary to fix the economy.

"Americans are angry, they're upset and they're a little fearful," McCain said of the economy.

Calling the global downturn the "worst financial crisis since the Great Depression," Obama blamed President Bush and, by association, McCain, whom he said supported the failed policies of the Bush administration.

"I believe this is a final verdict on the failed economic policies of the last eight years, strongly promoted by Bush and supported by McCain," he said.

McCain Aimed to Turn the Tide

In the days leading up to the debate, McCain said he wanted to shift the national dialogue away from the ongoing economic crisis and onto Obama's character.

The two were expected to hammer out clear differences, and the second meeting between the candidates was seen as a chance for McCain to reverse a recent slide in the polls, leaving him trailing in key battleground states.

Both men took the opportunity to make small digs at each other, but the debate contained none of the personal, ad hominem negative attacks that pundits had predicted.

McCain questioned Obama's tax policy, saying, "Nailing down Sen. Obama's various tax proposals is like . The last president to raise taxes during tough economic times was Hoover."

To which Obama parried: "I think the straight talk express lost a wheel on that one."

The town hall style debatewas moderated by Tom Brokaw of NBC News, who asked just a handful of the hundreds of thousands of questions submitted over the Internet.

Another dozen or so questions were asked by a group of 80 undecided voters from the Nashville area selected by the Gallup Poll.

McCain favors the town hall format and had previously challenged Obama to other town hall debates, a fact that led to the evening's first zinger.

"It's good to be with you at a town hall meeting," McCain said to Obama, who had refused McCain's invitation to meet for weekly town hall debates.

Dialogue Fails to Spark in Obama, McCain Town Hall

The town hall style never fully took off, with the candidates rarely engaging the audience or each other, and Brokaw chiding the candidates for not sticking to the time limits.

Asked whom each would nominate as Treasury secretary in their respective administrations, McCain suggested former eBay CEO Meg Whitman, while Obama suggested Berkshire Hathaway CEO Warren Buffett.

Both took the opportunity to blame each other for playing a role in causing the economic crisis.

McCain accused Obama of receiving donations form individuals at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the mortgage giants whose failures signaled the oncoming crisis.

"There were some of us who stood up against this," he said. "There were others who took a hike."

Obama has received $126,349 ($120,349 from employees and $6,000 from Political Action Committees, or PACs) since he joined the Senate in 2005, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.

His total is the second-largest of any member of Congress, right behind Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn., at $165,400.

McCain has received $21,550 from employees (nothing from PACs) since 1989 -- a period 14 years longer than Obama has been in the Senate -- again according to the Center for Responsive Politics.

Obama said he was the real reformer of the two, who had called on Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke to take action while McCain was waiting for the free market to correct itself.

"I've got to correct Sen. McCain's history, not surprisingly. Deregulation of the financial system ... Sen. McCain, as recently as March, bragged about the fact that he's a deregulator. Two years ago I said there was a subprime crisis we had to deal with. I wrote to Paulson and Bernanke and told them it's something we need to deal with. I never promoted Fannie Mae."

Then Obama switched tacks, speaking directly to Oliver Clark, the audience member who had asked a question about the bailout, saying, "You're not interested in politicians pointing fingers. You're interested in the impact on you. This is not the end, this is the beginning of the process."

Asked if that meant he believed the economy was poised to get much worse, Obama said, "I am confident about the American economy, but we are going to have to have to leadership from Washington."

McCain, Obama on Attacking Pakistan

The two men clashed over whether the United States military should make cross-border excursions into Pakistan to fight suspected militants, offering different perspectives on how the United States should flex its might and turning the issue into a question of leadership.

McCain accused Obama of pandering and emboldening American enemies by announcing the military strikes he would take in advance.

"I'm not going to telegraph my punches, which is what Sen. Obama did," said McCain, adding that he follows the lead of his hero Teddy Roosevelt, who said the United States should "talk softly but carry a big stick."

In that heated exchange, Obama accused McCain of hypocrisy.

"This is a guy who sang 'bomb, bomb, bomb Iran,' who called for the annihilation of North Korea -- that I don't think is an example of speaking softly."

McCain said Obama "was wrong about Iraq and the surge. He was wrong about Russia when they committed aggression against Georgia. And in his short career he does not understand our national security challenges. We don't have time for on-the-job training."

Energy and Oil

Both men conceded that the nation's energy policy needed to be changed but disagreed on how best to end American reliance on foreign oil.

"I've disagreed strongly with the Bush administration on this issue. I've traveled all over the world to look at greenhouse gas emissions," said McCain.

"What's the best way of fixing it? Nuclear power. I was on Navy ships that had nuclear power plants. Nuclear power is safe and clean. I know that we can reprocess the spent nuclear fuel. The Japanese, British and French do it. Obama opposes that."

Obama said McCain had voted 23 out of 26 times against alternative fuel bills presented to the Congress and said he supported nuclear power, in addition to solar, wind and thermal energy.

"This is one of the biggest challenges of our time, and it's absolutely critical we understand it's not a challenge, it's an opportunity," he said. "I've called for investments in solar, wind, thermal. I favor nuclear power as one component of our energy mix, but I think this is another example of where we have to look at the record."

Health Care Takes Focus on Presidential Debate Stage

Any common ground they found on energy was lost in their divergent plan on health care. McCain called health care a "responsibility," while Obama called it a "right."

McCain wants to give families a $5,000 tax break that would allow them to look for affordable health care that best met their needs.

Obama, on the other hand, wants to continue with the current system, in which employees receive coverage through their jobs, but augment it with government funding to help the uninsured.

"If you've got health care already, and probably the majority of you do, then you can keep your plan if you're satisfied with it. We're going to work with your employer to lower the cost of your premiums by as much as $2,500 a year. If you don't have health insurance, you're going to be able to buy the same kind of insurance McCain and I enjoy as federal employees," Obama said.

Obama said McCain's plan would require taxes on the benefits workers receive from their employers and wipe out the ability of states to enforce regulations requiring certain tests, such as mammograms.

McCain said that Obama's plan would penalize small business owners and parents.

"If you're a small-business person and you don't insure your employees, he'll fine you," McCain said of Obama. "If you're a parent and you're struggling to get health care for your children, he'll fine you."

Down in the polls, McCain and his running mate, Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, went on the offensive last weekend, aggressively attacking Obama for his association to 1960s radical William Ayers, a move some see as part of a last-ditch attempt to revive a flagging campaign.

McCain still has time and hopes that the attacks will swing the momentum in several important battleground states.

In Pennsylvania, Obama leads 48 to 38; and in Florida, 48 to 46, according to latest battleground polls monitored by ABC News' Polling Unit.

And a new ABC News/Washington Post poll indicates Obama has taken a commanding lead in Ohio, where days ago the two were virtually tied, in large part because of the area's economic difficulties.

Obama now leads McCain 51-45 percent among likely voters in Ohio, according to the poll.

Though 18 percent of the respondents said they had not yet made up their minds for sure, Obama had the advantage of the sheer energy of his backers: Fifty-eight percent of his Ohio supporters are "very enthusiastic" about his candidacy, compared with 30 percent of McCain's.