ANALYSIS: Why the New Independent Candidate Could Still Matter

Evan McMullin could be Donald Trump’s worst nightmare.

— -- Calling him a long shot underestimates the odds.

“She fails the basic tests of judgment and ethics any candidate for president must meet,” McMullin wrote of Clinton.

Turning to Trump, McMullin said that to elect him “would be deeply irresponsible.”

“Republicans are deeply divided by a man who is perilously close to gaining the most powerful position in the world, and many rightly see him as a real threat to our republic,” McMullin wrote.

This all might seem like an attempt to script a “Dave” in a world of “House of Cards” — if not a “Punk’d” for politics. McMullin has never held elected office, and he entered the day he announced his candidacy with barely 100 Twitter followers.

Given those realities, Trump’s message to conservatives has been simple. “You have no choice,” he said the week before last, citing the need for conservative justices on the Supreme Court.

McMullin won’t and can’t compete everywhere. Yet he doesn’t have to in order to complicate Trump’s already narrow path to an Electoral College majority.

Take McMullin’s native state of Utah and its six electoral votes. That’s as red a state as you could design but also as anti-Trump as any. Ted Cruz won nearly 70 percent of the vote in its caucuses, with Trump running a distant third.

Nevada and Arizona, two other states with sizable Mormon populations (McMullin is a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) as well as large numbers of Hispanics, could also prove more difficult for Trump with another option on the table. Virtually any battleground state could tip toward Clinton if enough Republican votes find someplace else to go.

The next move is McMullin’s. He’ll need to begin to deliver a message as a first-time candidate and use the campaign machinery that was erected in expectation of a candidacy to disseminate a message.

But it just might be that conservatives view this election as worth the risk of spoiling. More to the point, he can succeed if they already consider the year to have been spoiled.