The "Vacation" star spoke, kind of, more about the incident on "Watch What Happens Live," revealing a few details about that night.
"How many fifths do I get?" the actress said when asked who the guy was she left Pitt for.
Then, she joked: "I don't have to do nothing" when it comes to answering the tough question.
But, she did say he was not an actor, but was known to the public.
Applegate didn't date the guy she ditched Pitt for, but she didn't get to rekindle the romance with Pitt again either, admitting she never went on another date.