Poll: Less Job Security is the "New Normal"

Half think future job security will be worse than before the recession.

December 15, 2008, 12:03 PM

June 15, 2009— -- Battered by the worst recession in decades, vast numbers of Americans see lean times ahead for the long term – and plan to recalibrate their lives accordingly.

Two concerns stand out in particular: Half the population in this new ABC News poll thinks both job security and retirement prospects in the years ahead will remain worse than their pre-recession levels. Four in 10 also see worsened prospects for the availability of jobs and advancement, and, consequently, their own spending power.

Click here for PDF with charts and full questionnaire.

Those diminished expectations – plus the pain of the current downturn – are fueling retrenchments in consumer behavior that could fundamentally reshape the economy. Majorities in this national survey say they plan in the years ahead to spend less, save more, invest more conservatively and, above all, to cut their credit card debt.

The ultimate extent of this potential realignment depends on the depth of the recession and nature of the recovery that follows. But consumer pullback already is well under way: Retail sales in May were down 9.6 percent from a year earlier, consumer credit declined at an annual rate of 7.5 percent in April and the savings rate hit a 14-year high.

With consumer spending accounting for an estimated 70 percent of economic activity, these changes are profound. What lies ahead could be even more so.

Ongoing polling by ABC News has documented the extent of consumer pain to date. While there's been a largely politically inspired rise in expectations that the worst is over (chiefly among Democrats expressing confidence in the Obama administration), ratings of current economic conditions remain near their record low in 23 years of weekly polling, with rising gasoline prices threatening to darken the picture further.

This new survey, part of a weeklong ABC News series, "The New Normal," moves the discussion to more forward-looking measurements, asking Americans whether they think long-term economic conditions will regain, exceed or be worse than their pre-recession levels – and their own intentions to spend, save and take on debt in the future.

Fewer Luxury Purchases in the Future

In the biggest intended shift, a remarkable 66 percent say they'll be less willing in the years ahead to take on credit card debt, with 52 percent "much" less willing to do so – the highest intensity pullback by far. More than half also say they're less apt to take out loans or a mortgage, invest in the stock market or spend money overall.

And two-thirds insist they'll try harder to save.

EXPECTATIONS – The potential trends look especially grim for luxury and big-ticket products, better for budget-based indulgences. Fifty percent of Americans expect their ability to afford "larger luxuries" to remain worse than it was before the recession, while just 16 percent see it improving beyond its pre-recession level. From new cars to jewelry to high-end holidays, today's troubles could well linger.

But even on basics the picture's not good: Over the long term anywhere from 40 to 43 percent – huge numbers of consumers – don't expect the availability of jobs to regain its pre-recession levels and see worsened advancement opportunities for those who do have work. Equally as many expect a diminished ability to afford things they want and need in general, and, in one particular, anticipate greater difficulty paying for health care.

As noted, even more, 51 and 50 percent respectively, think job security and their ability to afford a comfortable retirement will remain worse than before the downturn began.

Each of these far exceeds the number who expect things in the future to be better than they were before the recession. The number of pessimists also surpasses those who think things simply will return to their pre-recession levels, but not advance beyond them.

There is one less glum outlook: Substantially fewer, 29 percent, think their ability to afford "small luxuries," like dining out, will be worse than it was before the recession began. More think this will go back to its pre-recession status. (Think, perhaps, McDonald's, which managed a 2.8 percent increase in U.S. same-store sales in May.)

FACTORS – Expectations of future economic conditions are by nature speculative, informed by political as well as economic judgments. Such is the case now: Republicans, with their far lower confidence in President Obama, have a much more negative view, Democrats much less so, with independents between the two.

Democrats and Republicans Differ on Job Prospects

Fifty-one percent of Republicans, for instance, think jobs will remain harder to find than before the recession began; just 30 percent of Democrats agree. Republicans likewise are about 20 points more apt to think health care costs, job stability and their own ability to afford things will be worse long-term than they were pre-recession.

Negative expectations also peak among 45- to 54-year-olds, whose ranks include mid- to late-career workers perhaps beginning to assess their life savings as they eye retirement. Expectations are least negative, by contrast, among the youngest adults, age 18 to 29, with the longest time frame for careers and savings alike.

Among other differences, men are 6 to 9 points more negative than women on job-specific metrics – availability, stability and advancement opportunities alike. And there are a few other issue-specific differences: Upper-income Americans are far less glum about being able to afford "small luxuries" and a little less negative about paying for "larger" ones. That holds out some slight hope for higher-end retailers, since better-off adults are their prime market.

Higher-income adults also are less wary than others of the stock market – but still 41 percent of those in $100,000-plus households say they'll be less willing in the future to invest in equities, two in 10 "much" less willing to do so. These jump to 58 percent less willing, 38 percent "much" less willing, among less well-off Americans.

There also are some regional differences, with expectations for job availability, security and advancement opportunities more negative in the Midwest (and to some extent in the Northeast) than elsewhere.

SPENDING PLANS – Such factors have little effect, though, on personal spending and saving intentions, where plans for retrenchment are similar across the board. Here the strong impact is expectations themselves: People who have more negative views of the future economy are more apt to plan to cut back.

Some of these differences are dramatic. Among people who think their ability to save for retirement will be worse in the future than it was pre-recession, 74 percent say they'll be less willing to spend money overall. That dives to just a third of those who see their retirement savings prospects as better or the same as before.

In another example, among people who doubt future job stability, 68 percent say they're less apt to be willing to take out a mortgage or other loans in the future; that falls to 42 percent of those who have less concerns about job stability looking ahead.

Such results underscore the impact of future conditions; if factors such as job stability and the ability to save for retirement improve beyond expectations, consumer cutbacks could be less dire than now anticipated. If not, the "new normal" may well come to pass.

METHODOLOGY – This ABC News poll was conducted by telephone June 3-7, 2009, among a random national sample of 1,001 adults. Results for the full sample have a 3.5-point error margin; click here for a detailed description of sampling error. Sampling, data collection and tabulation by TNS of Horsham, PA.

ABC News Live

ABC News Live

24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events