Timothy Olson, Wisconsin man accused of victimizing women he meets on dating apps, taken into custody

Timothy Olson was also wanted for questioning in a woman's death.

November 29, 2022, 5:27 PM

A Wisconsin man accused of financially preying on women he met on dating apps, and is wanted for questioning in connection with the death of a woman he was with when she collapsed at a bar, has been taken into custody, police said.

Police had warned the public to be on the lookout for Timothy Olson, 52, for several weeks. He was being sought by multiple police departments in the Milwaukee area, including one with a warrant out for his arrest for alleged personal ID theft. Another warned that Olson "has met women on dating apps and victimizes them, resulting in financial loss."

In this photo released by the Racine Police Department, Timothy Olson is shown.
Racine Police Department

Amid attempts to locate him, Olson was spotted in Franklin, a city in Milwaukee County, Monday night at a business on South 27th Street, police said.

"Please be on the look out for TIMOTHY OLSON," the Franklin Police Department said on Facebook Tuesday while sharing two photos of Olson. "Do not attempt to contact or apprehend him. Call 911 immediately to report his location."

An "observant" officer spotted a man believed to be Olson on the street Tuesday morning around 10:15 a.m., Franklin Police Chief Rick Oliva told reporters during a press briefing. As officers approached, he fled into a nearby condominium complex and after a "brief struggle" was tased and taken into custody, Oliva said.

Olson faces charges of kidnapping, burglary and identity theft in connection with an incident in Franklin involving a 79-year-old woman on Nov. 23, Oliva said.

After a woman declined his offer for a drink at a local bar, Olson later allegedly approached her in the parking lot with a gun and forced her into her car and "held her for a number of hours," including forcing her to drive to at least one ATM, Oliva said. He allegedly took one of her credit cards and withdrew cash, Oliva said. The suspect also was allegedly involved in at least two burglaries in Franklin before his arrest, Oliva said. She was unharmed but "very shook up," he said.

Olson was in the custody of the Franklin Police Department Tuesday afternoon being interviewed by detectives from the police departments in Franklin, Racine and South Milwaukee, Oliva said. It's unclear if he has an attorney who can speak on his behalf.

"We're glad he's off the street," Oliva said. "There's no doubt this person would continue to do what he did until caught."

Link to woman's death in South Milwaukee

South Milwaukee police were seeking to speak with Olson amid an investigation into the death of 55-year-old Kim Mikulance. The two were at Powers on 10th in South Milwaukee on Nov. 17 when Mikulance had an "unknown medical emergency," police said. She was transported to a local hospital where she died five days later, police said.

Surveillance video showed Mikulance and Olson sitting together at the bar before she collapsed, police said.

The South Milwaukee Police Department said it is investigating the incident at Powers on 10th and is awaiting the autopsy results.

"At this time, the investigation is ongoing and it is not known if any crime has occurred, or if this incident is related to any other investigations by other jurisdictions," the department said in an update on Nov. 22.

The Milwaukee County Medical Examiner's Office confirmed that Mikulance died on Nov. 22, and that the South Milwaukee Police Department has placed a non-disclosure order on her case, meaning no further details can be released at this time.

Surveillance footage shows Kim Mikulance and Timothy Olson, both unblurred, together in a bar on Nov. 17, 2022. Police said Olson is a person of interest in the investigation of Mikulance's death. He is not a suspect at this time.

Sam Anderson told ABC Milwaukee affiliate WISN she was bartending at Powers on 10th when she saw Mikulance, a Cudahy resident who was a regular at the bar, collapse.

"I saw the look on her face and I saw she was holding a drink and she kind of started leaning back," Anderson told the station. "She was in here for maybe five minutes until she hit the ground."

For now, friends of Mikulance -- a mother of four who went by Raina -- are left searching for answers.

"There's a lot of conversation going on as to what went down. And we really don't know," her friend, Marc Gaidish, told WISN.

Racine police also seeking suspect for 'similar incident'

The incident at Powers on 10th marked the third time a woman has fallen unconscious while in Olson's presence, according to police in Racine, about 15 miles south of South Milwaukee.

Police in Racine have been warning women in the area about Olson for several weeks.

On Nov. 9, the Racine Police Department issued a safety alert to "caution the women in Racine County and get the public's help in locating a male subject who has met women on dating apps and victimizes them, resulting in financial loss."

Olson has a warrant out for his arrest for five counts of felony personal ID theft for financial gain issued by police in nearby Mt. Pleasant, according to the Racine Police Department. The warrant stems from a Sept. 2 incident, court records show.

"The Racine Police Department is looking to speak to Olson regarding a similar incident out of our jurisdiction," the department said.

No further details can be released at this time on the incident in their jurisdiction amid a "very ongoing and active" investigation, Sgt. Kristi Wilcox, a spokesperson for the Racine Police Department, told ABC News.

The Racine Police Department issued another warning on Nov. 21, updating that Olson had been linked to "another woman in a bar who fell unconscious while in his presence" on Nov. 17. That incident was the one that occurred at Powers on 10th, Wilcox confirmed.

That incident marked the third woman Racine police are aware of to have "ended up unconscious" while in Olson's presence, the department said.

Other victims likely, chief says

Oliva said police are working to determine where Olson was living and if he had any association to Franklin. He has relatives in the area, the chief said.

Olson has given a statement to Franklin police, though Oliva said could not provide any additional details at this time.

Police across the jurisdictions are continuing to work through evidence, he said.

"These are active investigations," he said. "There's a lot of evidence to be processed."

Oliva said it's "likely" there are there other alleged victims of Olson, including some who may have been "embarrassed" to come forward.

Now that he's in custody, he said it's possible some will contact their local police.

"Hopefully that will be the case," Oliva said.

Asked why the suspect was still in the area while businesses and residents were advised to be on the lookout for him, Olson said, "We're interested in finding that out, too."