E. Jean Carroll defamation case: Judge denies Trump's motion for mistrial

A jury ordered Donald Trump to pay Carroll $83 million for defaming her.

Former President Donald Trump, at the end of a five-day trial, has been ordered to pay $83.3 million in damages to former Elle magazine columnist E. Jean Carroll for defaming her in 2019 when he denied her allegations of sexual abuse.

Last year, in a separate trial, a jury determined that Trump was liable for sexually abusing Carroll in the dressing room of a Manhattan department store in the 1990s, and that he defamed her in a 2022 social media post by calling her allegations "a Hoax and a lie" and saying "This woman is not my type!"

Trump has denied all wrongdoing and has said he doesn't know who Carroll is.


0

Trump's request for mistrial is meritless, Carroll's lawyer argues

E. Jean Carroll's attorney has asked the judge in the case to promptly deny former President Trump's request for a mistrial.

In a letter to the judge on Sunday, lawyer Roberta Kaplan accused Trump's defense team of creating a "spectacle" when they requested a mistrial in front of the jury last week.

On Friday, Trump attorney Alina Habba, in a written request, renewed her request for a mistrial in the case by arguing that Carroll failed to preserve evidence when she deleted some the death threats she received after she accused Trump of sexual assault in 2019.

In her response, Carroll's attorney argued that Carroll's testimony has been consistent with her past statements, and Habba merely muddled the issue during her cross-examination.

"This muddled testimony, which resulted from muddled and shouted questions, is hardly sufficient to carry Mr. Trump's burden of demonstrating that Ms. Carroll deleted evidence when she was under an obligation to preserve it," Kaplan wrote.

Kaplan added that Carroll had not filed her lawsuit when she initially deleted some of the death threats that filled her inbox in 2019, and that Habba's request to preclude the jury from considering damages for the death threats would unfairly limit the jury's role.


Trump expected to attend trial, possibly testify Monday

Former President Trump is expected to attend the trial on Monday, sources tell ABC News, cautioning that the former president's plans are flexible.

Lawyers for E. Jean Carroll plan to call former Elle editor-in-chief Robbie Myers on Monday morning as their final witness, after which Trump's attorneys plan to call Trump to the stand, followed by Carol Martin, a former television newswoman with whom Carroll confided about Trump's alleged assault.

Once the defense rests its case, Carroll's team could present a brief rebuttal case before closing statements.

Trump attorney Alina Habba told the court that the defense's case would run roughly two days.


Trump's attorney renews request for mistrial

Trump attorney Alina Habba renewed her request for a mistrial in the case Friday, arguing that E. Jean Carroll failed to preserve evidence when she deleted the death threats she received after she accused Trump of sexual assault in 2019.

"Despite being served with a subpoena in connection with this action, Plaintiff failed to take reasonable steps to preserve relevant evidence. In fact, she did much worse -- she actively deleted evidence which she now attempts to rely on in establishing her damages claim," Habba wrote in a letter to Judge Lewis Kaplan Friday.

Habba originally requested a mistrial during her cross-examination of Carroll on Wednesday, which Kaplan immediately denied.

Carroll explained during cross-examination that she deleted some emails and messages that were "filled with threats" before 2023.

"I deleted them early on because I didn't know how to handle death threats. I had no idea," Carroll testified. "I thought deleting them was the smartest, best, quickest way to get it out of my life."

Renewing her request in writing Friday, Habba asked for Judge Kaplan to either declare a mistrial, preclude Carroll from seeking damages based on the death threats, or instruct the jury about the "spoliation of relevant evidence."


'Trump has the right to defend himself,' his attorney says

Concluding her testimony after two days on the witness stand, E. Jean Carroll offered no remarks to reporters as she exited court, briefly hugging her lawyers before entering an SUV.

Speaking outside court, Donald Trump's counsel Boris Epshteyn said he doubted that Judge Lewis Kaplan would follow through on his threat to kick Trump out of the courtroom should the former president testify on Monday when court resumes.

"I have absolutely zero concerns," Epshteyn said. "President Trump has the right to defend himself."


Carroll 'failed to show' she deserves damages, defense says

Trump attorney Alina Habba, in her closing argument, questioned the sincerity of E. Jean Carroll's claims of emotional and professional harm and accused her of trying to pin the comments of Twitter trolls on a president of the United States.

"Ms. Carroll has failed to show she is entitled to any damages at all," Habba said.

Habba attempted to suggest that Donald Trump could not defend himself and that Carroll had paid for a lawyer for her friend Carol Martin, who testified as a hostile witness for the defense -- but Carroll's attorneys objected and Judge Lewis Kaplan sustained the objection.

"If you violate my instructions again, Ms. Habba, there could be consequences," the judge warned.

Habba said that Carroll failed to prove causation, slowly annunciating the word loudly into the microphone.

"They have to prove a direct causal connection between the harm they say she suffered and [Trump's] statements," Habba said, arguing that there were independent critics messaging Carroll before Trump issued his defamatory statements denying Carroll's June 2019 sexual assault allegation.

"This is the beauty and dangers of free speech in America. Everyone is entitled to their opinion," Habba said, asserting that Trump has no more control over the thoughts and feelings of social media users "than he does the weather."

"It is Ms. Carroll's burden, not President Trump's, to prove his statements are the cause of any harm, and clearly she has failed to meet that burden," Habba argued.

She also questioned the legitimacy of the harm Carroll claims to have suffered. "Who is E. Jean?" Habba asked, telling the jury there are two versions, and asserting that the true E. Jean Carroll is a narcissist out for fame and attention, "and the one who comes to court to get money from my client."

Habba also chided Carroll for deleting messages containing death threats -- which Carroll said she did because they were painful to see -- and for never calling the police.

"She deleted her own evidence," Habba said. "She has to give them to you to support their claim for damages, but they're not here and that's a fact."

As Trump looked on, hunched forward, hands folded on the table, Habba quoted his brief testimony saying he did not intend to hurt Carroll.

"We do not know the true identities of the people who sent the messages to Ms. Carroll," Habba said. "President Trump should not have to pay for their threats. He does not condone them. He did not direct them. All he did was tell his truth."