The couple told "Good Morning America" they received a letter that read, "please remove the snowman until closer to the holiday season."
"It doesn't state any dates at all on when to put the decorations [back] up," Nick Simonis told "GMA." "It only stated that we must take down the decorations ten days after the holidays."
Diamond Association Management & Consulting, the Simonis Homeowner Association, has not yet responded to ABC News' request for comment.
One of the Simonis' reasons for their early decking of the halls is because Claudia is 8-months pregnant.
"I just wanted to be prepared," she told "GMA."
One of the Simonis' neighbors told "GMA" she was "furious" when she heard about the issue.
"It's not bothering anyone, it's gorgeous," the neighbor said.
Despite the notice, the Simonis said they're not removing their Christmas decor.
"We're definitely keeping them up," Nick Simonis said. "We're not taking them down at all."