Casey Anthony Trial: Witness Rebuts Human Decomposition in Car's Trunk

Chemist says tests of air samples from car trunk don't show human decomposition.

June 22, 2011, 11:04 AM

June 22, 2011 — -- A forensic chemist testifying in the Casey Anthony trial said today that the car belonging to the Florida mom accused of murdering 2-year-old daughter Caylee did not test positive for human decomposition.

Michael Sigman, a chemist at the National Center for Forensic Science, said that air samples from Casey Anthony's car trunk tested positive mainly for gasoline. Chloroform and two other chemicals were present.

"I could not conclusively determine that the presence of those compounds indicated that there had been human remains in the trunk of that car," Sigman told jurors.

Casey Anthony, 25, is accused of murdering Caylee in the summer of 2008. She could face the death penalty if convicted.

The prosecution has argued that Caylee died from chloroform and duct tape placed over her nose and mouth. The defense argues that she actually drowned in the family pool on June 16, 2008, 31 days before she was reported missing.

Sigman's testimony casts shadow over the prosecution's star witness, Dr. Arpad Vass. Vass testified earlier this month that the trunk of Casey Anthony's car had an abundance of chloroform, a sign of human decomposition and a chemical that also can be used to commit murder.

Evidence photos in Casey Anthony murder trial

Sigman originally collected air samples from the Pontiac Sunfire's trunk in July 2008. One of his air samples was sent to Vass to analyze. Sigman then analyzed another sample on his own.

"The results of that test were consistent with the presence of gasoline," Sigman said.

Sigman collected five more air samples from the car's trunk using different methodologies to concentrate the sample. Those samples showed gasoline, chloroform and two other chemicals.

Sigman said chloroform is frequently found in bleach.

Casey Anthony Trial Sticks to Forensics

Upon cross examination, Sigman said that the methodologies he used to analyze the samples was not as good as the method used by Vass.

Sigman used tedlar bags to collect air samples. He also collected samples using two other methodologies in an attempt to concentrate the samples to gain a better reading. Those methods were the collection of solid phase microfiber samples and the use of activated carbon strips.

Vass's results came from the use of a triple sorbent trap.

Along with the sample sent to him from Sigman, Vass also reviewed samples from the carpet of the trunk. When he opened a can containing a sample from the car's trunk, he was struck by the odor.

"I essentially jumped back a foot or two…I was shocked that that little itty bitty can could have that much odor associated with it…I would recognize it as human decomposition," Vass told jurors on June 6.

Vass works at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee where he analyzes the odor of death by working with cadavers at a "body farm."

Vass said that chloroform is normally found in trace amounts, in parts per trillion. The trunk sample showed chloroform in the parts per million range, significantly higher than the average.

Upon cross examination, Sigman told prosecutors that Casey Anthony's trunk did smell, but because he doesn't study human decomposition, he couldn't say the car reeked of death.

During today's abbreviated hearing, the defense continued to focus on scientific evidence.

Gatorade Bottle With Syringe Found With Caylee's Remains

An FBI toxicologist said that hair samples from Caylee's skull did not test positive for xanax, valium, rufies and six other drugs. The hair was not tested for chloroform. The toxicologist acknowledged that testing hair is not the best way to see if someone was drugged.

Two other experts testified about a Gatorade bottle containing a syringe found in a red Disney bag near Caylee's remains. Caylee's skull was found on Dec. 11, 2008 in a wooded area near the Anthony family home.

The "cool blue" Gatorade bottle contained a "whitish, murky liquid," said Michael Rickenbach, a forensic chemist with the FBI.

Rickenbach said that the liquid seemed to be some type of cleaning solution and a mix of testosterone. He said that low levels of chloroform were present, but chloroform is often found in cleaning solutions. Its unclear what role the Gatorade bottle plays in the defense team's strategy.

Rickenbach also tested a car seat and steering wheel from Anthony's Pontiac Sunfire. Neither tested positive for chloroform, he said. A test of Caylee's favorite doll, found in the Pontiac Sunfire, tested positive for chloroform, but the levels were too low to be tested further, Rickenbach said.

The questions about the chloroform on the steering wheel and other objects appeared to suggest that if Casey Anthony had chloroform on her hands, it would have been on the steering wheel and other objects as well, but the judge blocked that line of questioning.

The continual focus on forensic evidence has done little to shed light on the defense's shocking opening statements that Caylee drowned and George Anthony, Casey Anthony's father, helped dispose of the body.

On Tuesday, the prosecution revealed that a one time jailhouse neighbor of Casey Anthony had come forward who had a story similar to Casey Anthony's defense.

April Whalen was assigned to a cell next to Casey Anthony for five days in 2009. Whalen's 15-month-old son, Isaiah, accidentally drowned in the family pool during a Christmas celebration in 2007. Whalen's father, Lynn Whalen, called 911.

Lynn Whalen told ABC News on Tuesday that he believed his daughter had talked to Casey Anthony while they were in jail together.

ABC News Live

ABC News Live

24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events