Model Survives Being Struck By Propeller

Model Lauren Scruggs was able to respond to voice commands today by moving her arms and legs, less than two days after the 23-year-old walked into the propeller of a small airplane, leaving her body severely mangled.
Scruggs had just got off of a two seater plane at a private airport in McKinney, Texas, Saturday night after looking at Christmas lights when she ran into the plane’s propeller. Her left hand, shoulder and face areas were hit.
The model, who also founded a lifestyle magazine, was rushed to Parkland Hospital in Dallas where her left hand was amputated.
She underwent several surgeries over the weekend and is now in stable condition. However the extent of her brain injury is still not known, family spokesperson Janee Harrell told ABCNews.com.
How Scruggs ran into the propeller remains unclear.
“It’s speculative at this point, but what we’re thinking is the plane landed and they were picking up the next passengers,” Harrell said. “It was dark and we think she probably turned around to thank the pilot.”
Harrell said Scruggs was not drinking at the time of the incident.
ABC News aviation consultant John Nance said incidents such as Scruggs’ are extremely rare and underscore the need for pilots to be especially clear in issuing safety directions.
“It sounds like this is a combination of a bad procedure by the pilot and the passenger not properly realizing her proximity,” Nance said. “One of the things I’d have to look at is why in the world a pilot permitted a passenger to board or deboard while a propeller was turning.”
For now, Scruggs’ recovery remains uncertain, but Nance said the model is extremely lucky.
“It’s like walking into a big Cuisinart,” he said. “I’m surprised it didn’t tear her in half.”

Email




RSS
Twitter
Facebook
John Nance = rocket scientist. Always getting his BRILLIANT 2 cents in and his name out there. Poor girl – def bad procedure by the pilot…he won’t leave it runnin’ again to save time. The insurance company is going to have a day with this one. SHUT IT DOWN. Then open the door. Watch your step. Easy peasey.
Posted by: Justa Plane Girl | December 5, 2011, 5:23 pm 5:23 pm
This blonde got propelled onto a whole new level.
Posted by: Sam | December 5, 2011, 5:36 pm 5:36 pm
How did she not feel the wind from that propeller, or hear the noise? It seems it would be impossible to miss.
Posted by: Shannon | December 5, 2011, 6:50 pm 6:50 pm
so sad.
Posted by: Addy | December 5, 2011, 7:24 pm 7:24 pm
You’re right. The prop was impossible for her to miss. Usually, there is a wing strut on a small two seater plane that tends to prevent this type of incident.
Posted by: Moe | December 5, 2011, 7:39 pm 7:39 pm
I noticed she was a blonde.
Posted by: uisignorant | December 5, 2011, 7:53 pm 7:53 pm
Some of you are so mean… Its a horrible thing to happen to anyone
Posted by: Dawn | December 5, 2011, 9:51 pm 9:51 pm
Shannon, I’m a pilot (private, not commercial), and depending on what direction a person is coming from, they may not feel the prop wash until it’s too late. (If there is more than one aircraft in the immediate area, they may feel prop wash coming from more than one direction, too.) Also, when the prop is spinning, you can’t see it.
Many people who aren’t used to being around small piston-driven aircraft are confused by the noises and sensations associated with them, and can do some really freaky things trying to get away from the noise and air flow when they’re around planes with spinning props. This is why, as a pilot, one of the first things I do when I’m taking someone to the airport to ride in a piston-driven airplane is explain to them that once they step out of the FBO building onto the apron where the aircraft are tied down, I become a dictator whose word is absolute law. I tell them where they stand, when they can talk to me, where they can walk and where they can’t, when and where they can enter the plane and leave the plane. And I tell them that this is a safety issue, and that if they don’t do as I say, then the flight terminates as soon as I can safely terminate it.
Without exception, first-time flyers in prop aircraft have all made the comment that they were surprised to find you can’t see the prop when it’s turning. And many people have commented to me that because they feel overwhelmed with the noise and the airflow caused by the prop when they’re standing near a plane with the prop turning, they can understand how easy it would be for someone to walk into a turning prop, especially if there are several aircraft in the area and it’s very noisy and confusing.
As for the comment by Moe about a wing strut, in a high-wing aircraft like a Cessna or Citabria, that might be true– but not always. The Cessna Cardinal is a high-wing aircraft that doesn’t have struts. And there are high-wing twin prop aircraft that don’t have struts. Also, low-wing aircraft, like the Piper Archer, don’t have struts.
FWIW, I’ve seen some crazy things happen with props. I’ve seen someone forget to take the tow bar off the front wheel before starting the prop, which caused a prop strike and sent the tow bar flying across the apron to hit another aircraft. I saw a guy who was flying from our FBO for the first time and who sent gravel flying into all the cars in the FBO parking lot when he started a plane facing the wrong way (we all knew to use tow the planes out away from the fence and turn them 90 degrees before starting). I’ve seen garbage cans get knocked over when someone turned their plane and the prop wash caught the can.
When you’re flying piston aircraft, you have to be a tyrant about people moving around near the prop. You just have to be very, very, very careful. And you never assume that other people will know there’s a spinning prop nearby, especially if they aren’t regular flyers themselves.
Posted by: cat whisperer | December 5, 2011, 10:13 pm 10:13 pm
So sorry to hear this, I hope you turn out ok, our most deeply simpaties to you and wish you a full recovery, may God be with you.
Posted by: Adalberto martinez | December 5, 2011, 10:45 pm 10:45 pm
Cat Whisperer, wow. That was an excellent explanation! Thank you for taking the time to write this.
Posted by: Shannon | December 5, 2011, 10:46 pm 10:46 pm
I worked very close to spinning props in Nam. I was one of the lucky ones. We lost 2 to the props while I was there. It’s easier to do than you think. Cat Whisperer is soooo right!
Posted by: GaryR | December 5, 2011, 11:44 pm 11:44 pm
Cat Whisperer – thanks for you comments. I recall taking private pilot lessons a few years back and everything you detailed is exactly right. Add to that it was night time, you can’t the prop spinning in the day time, so add spacial disorientation and the noise and there you go. I was always instructed to shut down the engine (and prop) before ANYBODY got out of the plane (pilot included). This is all pilot error. Poor girl.
Posted by: richie | December 5, 2011, 11:53 pm 11:53 pm
This is horrible and I can’t see how anybody could joke about it.
Posted by: lexingtonlady | December 6, 2011, 1:21 am 1:21 am
That’s right. It isn’t funny at all when somebody is suffering like that. I bet they wouldn’t think it’s funny if it happened to them.
Posted by: Elizabeth | December 6, 2011, 2:32 am 2:32 am
So sad, indeed. Best wishes for a good recovery. As for how this could happen, yes, thank you Cat Whisperer for details. As I have inner ear issues and become very dizzy, nauseated and tired from any travel, I can see how someone might have vertigo or other kinds of vestibular disorientation after getting off a plane. Wind and noise can really add to that and also spark the fight or flight adrenal response to just move and get to a calm place. The vision issues explained well above. Again, so very sorry to hear of this.
Posted by: Tia | December 6, 2011, 2:42 am 2:42 am
CAT WHISPERER, I appreciate your intelligent, helpful comment. Thank you.
Posted by: Mary | December 6, 2011, 4:49 am 4:49 am
A true terrible accident. Comments criticizing her are out of place. The best thing to do is to shut down the plane before allowing passengers to get off. I have been in many prop flights and the pilots I have flown with follow this procedure always.
Posted by: Bob Ramos | December 6, 2011, 4:52 am 4:52 am
Why do people act like they never made a mistake or had an accident,to you idiots that can’t help but joke about other peoples misfortunes,just remember It could be you next time ,I simply wonder how we can be of the same species?
Posted by: Compassionate One | December 6, 2011, 6:25 am 6:25 am
I just saw the story about this beautiful young woman on GMA. What a tragedy. After being in a serious auto accident myself last year, this story brought back a lot of emotions for me. I believe that the Lord has great plans for this young woman. Praying for her and her family.
Posted by: Carol Smith | December 6, 2011, 7:46 am 7:46 am
I work part time at the local airport and own an airplane. This makes me cringe.
Posted by: newcountryman | December 6, 2011, 8:08 am 8:08 am
I just saw this girls parents on good morning america. This is such a tragedy. We are praying for you Lauren.
You people who are making jokes about her and calling her a dumb blonde are only showing how little brain function you yourselves have. Nobody in their right mind would find this funny. Also there’s Karma…
Posted by: Kerrie | December 6, 2011, 9:05 am 9:05 am
Who walks into the propeller of a single-engine plane? I’ve spent 20 years working in, on, and around both propeller-driven aircraft and jets and I have never let my situational awareness go so low as to not know where it is safe to be. The pilot probably should have waited until the propeller had stopped spinning before allowing the passengers off (if only to avoid the inevitable lay suit) but there needs to be some personal responsibility on the part of the young lady. The article made it seem like she wasn’t completely unintelligent; but then, some of the most educated people I know don’t have enough common sense not to walk into a spinning propeller.
Posted by: Arf40 | December 6, 2011, 9:57 am 9:57 am
I am predicting that somehow a cell phone was involved – texting, taking a video, etc. College kids here (Boston) actually walk into the side of moving trains…while texting. A teen mother with a newborn walked in front of me a few weeks ago as I was driving 30 mph …. she was texting. And not blonde.
Posted by: nowthatithinkofit | December 6, 2011, 10:20 am 10:20 am
Maybe this was JUST God’s way of humbling her. The Lord works in mysterious ways yall. Only He will know why He planned this for her. Just be glad He has chosen to let her continue living her life. Maybe NOW she will take the opportunity to give herself totally to Him, before He plans for her to step in front of a speeding car. It’s obvious her heart was not completely open to Jesus. Otherwise He wouldn’t have pushed a plane’s running propellers into her face, laughing a silent invisible laugh the whole time. Praise the Lord. He had a plan for Lauren. Better get right with Jesus yall, or He will find a way to humble you too!
Now be honest, that would be a valid argument in regards to God saving her eye, etc. This was a horrible accident, whose blame most likely lies with the pilot for not shutting the plane off. In any case, no fictional character caused or could have prevented it from happening and same said fictional character will have no say in what happens to her eye. Pray to the Almighty Mickey Mouse. You’ll have equal IF NOT BETTER odds it will help.
Posted by: JC | December 6, 2011, 11:28 am 11:28 am
JC, are you serious? Why on earth would say such a thing like that?
Posted by: Alys | December 6, 2011, 1:19 pm 1:19 pm
@ NOWTHATITHINKOFIT….really? You come on here preaching Christianity and this was God’s way of humbling her? Did you know this young lady? I am a Christian as well, but I don’t feel the need to go around placing my judgement on ANYONE and especially not someone I do not know. I’m not sure about your Bible, but mine teaches me love, tolerance, and grace. Those 3 things are the way to show His love.
Posted by: 2cents | December 6, 2011, 1:25 pm 1:25 pm
I’m sorry that should’ve been directed @ JC not NOWTHATITHINKOFIT.
Posted by: 2cents | December 6, 2011, 1:27 pm 1:27 pm
I’m an Airline transport Pilot and fly small planes often and I can say that this happened due to pilot negligence. It is not the poor girls fault at all. The aircraft environment is unfamiliar to most people and with this happening at night, it is easy to do something this dangerous when you aren’t used to being around airplane and sometimes it’s worse if you are – you become complacent. The pilot should have thoroughly briefed as he is mandated to do IAW 14CFR Part 91 (Federal regulation), the danger areas of the aircraft and which path to take when walking away from / around the aircraft if he is going to be negligent enough and too lazy to stop the engine when having passengers leave the aircraft – especially in a high-wing aircraft.
This pilot is a fool and had the responsibility to take care of all of his passengers until the engine stopped. He should never be able to carry passengers again. This isn’t a dumb blonde issue, it’s a pilot safety issue. Lack of discipline and just laziness.
Posted by: ATP | December 6, 2011, 1:39 pm 1:39 pm
@JC, Don’t judge others. Golden rule, treat others as you would like to be treated. And love thy neighbor. I am praying for Lauren.
Cat Whisperer is right.
Posted by: Christian | December 6, 2011, 2:08 pm 2:08 pm
Some of the comments here are unbelievable, 1st this is Pilot Error and nothing else, as the Airline transport Pilot and CatWisperer stated there are procedures that were not followed that deal with the safety of his passengers. JC you really need some help there buddy, and I pray that God forgives you for your comments on this. Nobody speaks for God.
Posted by: Ben | December 6, 2011, 3:39 pm 3:39 pm
People wonder why this world is so effed up … just listen to some of the comments on here and it will become crys-tal …
Posted by: seriously now | December 6, 2011, 5:10 pm 5:10 pm
My understanding was she had gotten out, and was in front of the plane and safe. She then went back to thank the pilot on the pilot side and walked into the prop.
Posted by: Martin | December 6, 2011, 6:44 pm 6:44 pm
My deepest sympathy for Lauren and her family. Godspeed for a full recovery. Thank you Dawn (above) for the explanation about how this could happen. My older brother is a former Navy pilot and current private pilot. I recall his detailed instructions to each of us before he took us each up for a spin. At the time I thought he was being a little extreme when he yelled each time “All Clear” before starting engine, and “Sit tight” until prop stopped at end of flight.
Hopefully with Lauren’s youthfulness and loving family that they’ll all pull through this and be well.
Posted by: Ian | December 7, 2011, 12:32 am 12:32 am
Sorry, I meant Cat Whisperer as the contributor above. Stay strong Lauren and lean on family and friends like never before. They’ll lift you up until you can do it on your own.
Posted by: Ian | December 7, 2011, 12:55 am 12:55 am
Wow She is sooo beautiful….I hope your gonna be ok pretty lady!;0)
Posted by: Kathryn Compa | December 7, 2011, 4:36 am 4:36 am
“Say That” 2CENTS! Thanks a great deal for your explanation to those of us who didn’t know CAT WHISPERER!
Posted by: Kathy Womacke-Dials | December 7, 2011, 10:09 am 10:09 am
umm – how does someone walk into a plane propeller you ask? – how about she was listening to the blacked eyed peas with her headphones on—guaranteed that’s the reason she had no clue…
Posted by: RJR | December 7, 2011, 12:36 pm 12:36 pm
Pilot should be ashamed of himself. The assumption that folks outside of the aviation industry will know how to navigate around turning props is wrongheaded and mean-spirited.
This could have been this young lady’s first time ever around aircraft. I am always in control of my prop when it’s turning. And unlike ARF40, I reject the idea that it’s every man for himself out there.
Posted by: Dan Dasson ATP | December 7, 2011, 7:48 pm 7:48 pm
There is absolutely no excuse for this pilot’s actions. This accident is 100% on his or her shoulders. With this kind of judgement this pilots license should be revolked. I don’t want this person within a hundred miles of me in any aircraft.
Posted by: Carl Vincent / CFII | December 9, 2011, 11:09 pm 11:09 pm
This is a sad ,unfortunate event. Reading some of these comments about her reminds me of how people say kids can be cruel to one another …looks like the stupidity continues long after high school. Wow. Also @ jc I grew up going to church since I was an infant and saw many types of self-righteous people,judgemental people and people who just truly do not represent what Jesus is all about. The bible says judge not less you be judged. I wonder if these people even read the bible. Sounds a little like I’m judging myself …but jc I think its possible if you don’t change your way of thinking,you can live this life thinking your so high and mighty and HE will say to you on judgement day depart from me I never knew you. Let’s love people to God…not hate people into wanting a relationship with him. That doesn’t make sense. My thoughts and prayers are with this young lady and her family. It’s Christmas time. Let’s start loving each other.
Posted by: sandra d | December 10, 2011, 6:16 am 6:16 am
You don’t let some one out of your plane until the prop stops. So wh t if he/she as picking up another passenger – you need to shut down unless another pilot. pro or instructors is getting in. There is also a common-sense somsideration where in you (the now mangled girl) don’t approach a plane form thr front wiht a moving prop. That is just dumb on her part. I am sure we don’t have all the details but fault seems to be 70 pilot 30%passenger.
Sincerely,
Dr Mike
AME and private pilot (400 hrs)
Posted by: dr stretanski ane 01069 | December 11, 2011, 12:53 am 12:53 am
It’s funny how many people here are scolding others for judging this young woman, but they themselves don’t hesitate to leap to judge the pilot, even without knowing all the details. Look, you can’t fix stupid. What if, as some reports say, the pilot did everything right. He may have shut down, unloaded the aircraft, loaded back up and started up again. She was out, SAFE, clear at some point. She came BACK! Some reports say that he had just began to taxi when she ran back to the pilots side of the aircraft. Lets wait and see before ANY of you begin pointing fingers.
Posted by: LMAO | December 21, 2011, 2:01 pm 2:01 pm
Also, go read JC’s comments again. He was excessively brutal, but he is obviously an athiest, and the first paragraph was sarcasm. He does make a point, though as her recovery is being touted a “miracle”, yet no one is giving the almighty credit for the incident itself.
Posted by: Hmmm | December 21, 2011, 2:14 pm 2:14 pm
Why’s everyone blaming the pilot before even knowing the facts? My Dad has been a private pilot since I was 4 (I’m 31 now) and I’ve been flying with him since then. I can’t imagine any scenario where I would accidentally walk into a spinning propeller. Some are here saying that it’s easy to get confused…I’m sorry, I just don’t buy it. I know in busy airports (read: military in Nam) injuries like this happen. Those are terrible, but they’re not the norm. And when they do happen there’s usually a reason.
I also don’t understand why people are just assuming the pilot didn’t tell her to stay in the plane until the prop stopped. Maybe he did. Maybe she didn’t listen. Who knows.
Wait for the facts to come out then place blame.
Posted by: Why? | January 1, 2012, 9:23 pm 9:23 pm
Can you please email me the code for this script or please tell me in detail about this script?
Posted by: Russell Mank | January 18, 2012, 12:13 am 12:13 am
Way to go people, let’s keep coddling the idiots in the world. Person gets out of an airplane, with the engine running…ok, no big deal. Here’s the amazing part. This propeller she walks into (Remember, the headline is “model walks into propeller”, not “pilot runs over passenger”), is driven by a four or six cylinder piston engine, with no mufflers. In other words, LOUD. Not some ceiling fan driven by a whisper quiet electric motor. How stupid are the people of the world getting? Another example just yesterday is the man who shoots himself in the head with a nail gun, and we’re giving him his 15 min of fame for it?
What really confuses me is why this man is voluntarily getting in front of the camera so all the world can put a face to the stupidity they have heard about. These arent simple accidents America, we are interferring with God’s plan of weeding out the stupid ones by saving them. These people should not be allowed to procreate. Their brains are where knowledge goes to die.
Let’s stop making it socially acceptable to be ignorant
Posted by: NOTpoliticallycorrect | January 23, 2012, 4:16 pm 4:16 pm
I hear her career went into a tailspin.
Posted by: Anonymous | February 5, 2012, 12:57 am 12:57 am