By ABC News

Oct 23, 2011 9:20pm

GOP Rivals Tag Herman Cain a Flip-Flopper

ap herman cain nt 2 111018 wblog GOP Rivals Tag Herman Cain a Flip Flopper

(Isaac Brekken/AP Photo)

ABC News’ David Kerley and Jordyn Phelps report:

Despite the fact that the number one campaign issue on voters’ minds is jobs, contending Republican presidential candidates have spent much of the last week talking about abortion.

The sparring among the Republican candidates over the issue began after Herman Cain told CNN’s Piers Morgan Wednesday that while he is personally against abortion, the decision should ultimately lie with the family facing the choice — not the government.

“It ultimately gets down to a choice that the family or that mother has to make,” Cain told Morgan. “Not me as president, not some politician, not a bureaucrat. It gets down to that family. And whatever they decide. I shouldn’t have to tell them what decision to make for such a sensitive issue.”

Cain’s comments deviate from conservative Republican doctrine, which calls for a ban on all abortions. Cain has been leading in the polls, and the comments opened him up to a slew of attacks from competing candidates.

“It is a liberal canard to say I am personally pro-life but government should stay out of that decision,” Texas Gov. Rick Perry said Saturday night in a jab at Cain at the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition Presidential Forum. “If that is your view, you are not pro-life, you are pro having your cake and eating it too.”

Cain responded to Perry’s attack, defending his anti-abortion rights stance.

I am pro-life,” Cain said. ”I have said it I don’t know how many times.  That is an attempt to try and discredit me.”

Cain is not the only candidate who is receiving criticism for his abortion stances. Perry also took aim at Mitt Romney, who supported abortion rights when he was running for governor of Massachusetts.

“Being pro-life is not a matter of campaign convenience,” Perry said to a Christian audience Saturday in Iowa.

The Iowa caucuses are critical in determining the success or failure of a candidate’s presidential contest. And Cain has been scrambling to convince this important group of voters that he is a strong supporter of pro-life principles.

Speaking at the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition Presidential Forum, Cain sought to define himself as a strong pro-life supporter in clear terms.

“I believe abortion should be clearly stated as illegal across this country,” Cain said.

Despite Cain’s attempt to clarify his stance, many of the candidates are not convinced.

“Herman Cain’s out there, and he’s in his first real run for office and a serious campaign and I think he’s still finding his way through,” Santorum said following his speech at the Iowa Faith and Freedom forum.  “This is a pretty big and important race to be finding your way through issues, particularly on issues of this fundamental importance.”

He received further criticism today from Michele Bachmann, who called Cain out as a flip-flopper.

“You can’t have all of these flip-flops in our nominee,” Bachmann said on Fox News Sunday. “I think it’s giving people pause, and they’re asking real questions about, what does he believe, truly, and how would he govern as president of the United States? And I can tell you, here in Iowa, people want to make sure that our nominee is 100 percent pro-life.”

Conservative Christians have yet to rally around one particular candidate, but Cain’s recent stumble on abortion may give Romney, who has spent a lot of time and money on Iowa, the boost he is looking for among these early voters.

User Comments

Herman Cain beats Rick Perry when it comes to flip flops.

Posted by: Sarah | October 23, 2011, 10:48 pm 10:48 pm

What happened to the Republican party that actually believed in personal responsibility and “state’s rights”? Mr. Cain actually leaves the responsibility to the family and empowers the individual and these nanny-state Republicans want to shove their values on the rest of the nation. It makes me sick!

Fix the economy stupid! When people are empowered and they have a job/education then there is less likelihood for drug abuse, crime, abortion, etc. If you want to fix the ills of society, then start fixing the economy and let’s work on job creation and education. Abortion will take care of itself. Financially successful people are less likely to have abortions.

Lastly, can we please divorce the Republican party from the Christian movement? These people and their flat Earth beliefs have done more to damage this nation and the Republican ideals of personal responsibility and small government than any other movement. I don’t care about gay marriage. I don’t care about abortion. I don’t care! Fix the economy, shrink the federal govt. and let the states decide whether abortion, gun rights, medical marijuana, immigration, etc. is important. The federal government has failed. Let’s not empower the feds under another big government Republican like Bush or Cheney. Please Republicans… get your act together. Go back to your small govt. roots because the democrats surely aren’t going to do it.

Posted by: Pete | October 23, 2011, 11:23 pm 11:23 pm

Abortion is a privacy issue which should be handled at the federal level not the state.

Posted by: Jonathan | October 24, 2011, 12:11 am 12:11 am

Everyone is scared of this guy because he is rational, honest and can win. I believe that he was right the first time on abortion but so many fools out there want him to be a puppet. If he can stick to his convictions, he’s going to win this nomination and wipe the floor with Obama.

Posted by: Sho | October 24, 2011, 3:41 am 3:41 am

Agree with Pete and Sho. Abortion is really none of the business of the federal government. Whatever happened to the Republicans who wanted SMALLER, unintrusive government, and what is so small or unintrusive about telling citizens what they can do with their own bodies and whom they can marry? Who cares about abortion right now – sheesh!! The government should print money, regulate trade, conduct foreign affairs and settle disputes between states – that is all! Leave our private lives alone!

Perry, Bachmann and Sanitarium should leave Herman alone and stop trying to make him look bad, or else we’ll wind up with corporation puppet Romney, or worse yet, Obama again!

Posted by: Reason | October 24, 2011, 7:10 am 7:10 am

Agree with Pete and Sho. Abortion is really none of the business of the federal government. Whatever happened to the Republicans who wanted SMALLER, unintrusive government, and what is so small or unintrusive about telling citizens what they can do with their own bodies and whom they can marry? Who cares about abortion right now – sheesh!! The government should print money, regulate trade, conduct foreign affairs and settle disputes between states – that is all! Leave our private lives alone!

Perry, Bachmann and Sanitarium should leave Herman be and stop trying to make him look bad, or else we’ll wind up with corporation puppet Romney, or worse yet, Obama again!

Posted by: Gina | October 24, 2011, 7:14 am 7:14 am

His 15 minutes of fame is just about over. The real Herman Cain has been revealed for all to see. He never was a serious candidate but, just like Palin out to make money selling a book.

Posted by: Indymind | October 24, 2011, 7:16 am 7:16 am

Only in American politics one can never change their minds. How stupid….

Posted by: uisignorant | October 24, 2011, 7:16 am 7:16 am

John Keery is the master at flip flopping.

Posted by: newcountryman | October 24, 2011, 8:43 am 8:43 am

Excuse me, John Kerry.

Posted by: newcountryman | October 24, 2011, 8:43 am 8:43 am

FlipFlopping Newcountryman???? LOL…..

Posted by: uisignorant | October 24, 2011, 12:48 pm 12:48 pm

Leave a Reply

Do you have more information about this topic? If so, please click here to contact the editors of ABC News.