Can President Obama Win By Losing at the Supreme Court?

Mar 29, 2012 3:12pm
gty potus scotus thg 120329 wblog Can President Obama Win By Losing at the Supreme Court?

Image credit: Pete Souza/The White House/Getty Images

In the midst of a historic battle over health care at the Supreme Court, on the Bottom Line this week we’re taking a look at how the justices will handle the case and the potential fallout for the presidential campaigns. 

As ABC News’ Terry Moran points out, the court is not afraid of tackling big issues in the midst of an election. And after hearing the Justices’ tough questions during this week’s hearing, President Obama’s health care initiative might be in trouble. But then again, we’ve seen tough questioning in the past and then the court surprises us and upholds the law. 

Let’s take a look at what would happen if the court strikes down the law, and what that means for the presidential campaign. 

If the court strikes down the law it would be a huge blow to Obama, guaranteeing at least a week of negative coverage. When you lose you look weak, that’s what happens to a president. 

But if it’s a 5-4 partisan decision against the law, both Republican strategist Karl Rove and Democrat James Carville agree there could be a silver lining for Obama.

Rove pointed out in the Wall Street Journal  today that a partisan split would give Obama an opportunity to accept the court’s decision, reach back to the center and propose a new bipartisan initiative.

Carville argued that a narrow defeat gives Obama a chance to say “We tried,” and rally the base against the same court that decided Citizens United and Bush v. Gore.

My bottom line: A loss would be a huge blow to the administration, but the president could try both strategies to get an out.

Now what happens if the Supreme Court upholds the law? Take a look to find out:

SHOWS:
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus